Who Has Evan Peters Dated? His Dating History Includes 2 "American Horror Story" Costars

Evan Peters is one of the biggest heartthrobs in Hollywood, but when it comes to his real-life romances, his dating history is actually pretty small. While the 35-year-old actor — who currently stars on Netflix's new true-crime series "Monster: The Jeffrey Dahmer Story" — is known for his on-again, off-again romance with Emma Roberts, she certainly isn't the only star he's fallen for over the years. In fact, he actually dated one of his "American Horror Story: Murder House" costars way before the series even began.

In a 2015 interview with Cosmopolitan, the actor opened up about his dating preferences. Of the way to his heart, he said, "I guess girls who give me a chance, you know? If I say the wrong thing or do something stupid or fumble or spill sh*t on my shirt, she's OK with it. She's cool with that and will give me another chance to say the right thing, and get past my nerves and insecurity. Gotta give a guy a chance, essentially. There are a lot of girls out there who don't really want to do that. But there are a lot of girls out there who do, and those are the ones — the only ones — I can really go for. I need a couple more chances than just the first one."

See everyone who has called Peters their boyfriend, including Halsey, ahead.

01
Pixie Geldof
Getty

Pixie Geldof

Peters was first linked to the British model and singer when they were spotted holding hands and kissing at Coachella in 2010. They split up the following year.

02
Alexia Quinn
Getty

Alexia Quinn

The two first met in 2011 while working on a play called "Living at Home" and started dating shortly after. Quinn was by his side for his birthday in January 2012, but they split shortly after when Peters started filming "Adult World," which is coincidentally where he met Emma Roberts.

03
Alexandra Breckenridge
Getty

Alexandra Breckenridge

Way before "American Horror Story," the actor, who played a young Moira O'Hara during the first season, reportedly dated Peters. It's never been confirmed and there's no information on exactly how long they dated, but it's clear they're professionals since they worked together on "Murder House" after splitting.

04
Emma Roberts
Getty

Emma Roberts

The two first met on the set of "Adult World" in 2012 and started dating shortly after production wrapped. They later went on to play love interests on the third and fourth seasons of "American Horror Story." Though they have faced a number of breakups and makeups (and one nasty domestic-violence incident) over the years, the two ended their engagement in 2019 after seven years together.

05
Halsey
Getty

Halsey

The pair were first romantically linked during an outing to Six Flags Magic Mountain in September 2019. They then made their first public appearance as a couple for "American Horror Story"'s 100th episode party in October 2019. Their entire relationship seemed to be a manifestation of Halsey's seven-year crush, as she'd previously expressed her love for the actor via social media as early as 2012. In March 2020, Halsey removed all pictures of Peters from their Instagram, suggesting that the pair had broken up.