Remember when Jimmy Fallon [1] found out he totally had a chance with Nicole Kidman [2]? Well, we have another celebrity love story that never quite made it to "happily ever after." Jennifer Lawrence [3] made an appearance on Late Night With Seth Meyers on Tuesday night, and she came with an embarrassing story in tow. Turns out, when she hosted Saturday Night Live [4] years ago, she had a huge crush on Seth Meyers and devised a plan to ask him out. Things didn't really turn out as she'd hoped. The best part is, this whole thing reminds us of that Inside Amy Schumer sketch [5] in which "Amy Lake Blively" admits her long-standing crush on the late-night host of "Cliffley Lately." Watch Jen tell the story in the clip above.