Idina Menzel stopped by Jimmy Kimmel Live! on Wednesday night, where she ended up revealing her longtime crush on Matt Damon [1]. While it was always her dream to have the actor come backstage when she played Elphaba in Wicked [2] on Broadway, she told the host that once it finally happened, it didn't live up to her expectations. "He looked like he hated Wicked," she explained. "He just seemed so bored by it." However, Idina's spirits were quickly lifted when Jimmy put his little feud with Matt aside and connected the two via video chat. Spoiler alert: Matt actually loved Wicked and Idina. So cute!