Maya Erskine and Anna Konkle portray middle schoolers [1] in their hit Hulu show, PEN15 [2], but they actually reverted back to their teenage selves when they met their Y2K teen idol, Matthew Lawrence. During an appearance on Busy Tonight, the 31-year-old actresses [3] were surprised by the former Boy Meets World actor. Let's be completely honest: we would have the exact same reaction if we came face-to-face with our childhood celebrity crush [4]. After trying (and failing) to keep their cool, Matthew gave the actresses a nostalgic little gift. Watch the cute video ahead!