Skip Nav
These Sexy Shirtless Pictures Will Have You Chugging Water Like You're in the Sahara
Nina Dobrev
Nina Dobrev Flaunts Her Jaw-Dropping Figure While Working to Save Sharks in Hawaii
The Royals
11 Real-Life Princesses You Should Really Know About

Scarlett or Natalie?

While we loved seeing the great photos of Natalie and Scarlett in the March issue of W, the opening line of the article seemed a little far-fetched. It says, "It's not easy to find a man whose celebrity crush list includes both Natalie Portman and Scarlett Johansson." We certainly don't think that's true and lots of men would love a moment with either girl, but it got us thinking that everyone has to prefer one of these very different and both beautiful girls. So tell us, are you a Natalie or a Scarlett person?


Join The Conversation
DCStar DCStar 9 years
I like them both. Let's be positive here. They're both lovely, classy & smart. I've never seen either of them in compromising situations in the tabloids.
im-good im-good 9 years
There both very diferent girl's, i've seen alot of natalie though, I'm curious about scarlett, i wanna see more of her
belle102 belle102 9 years
natalie all the way
freegracefrom freegracefrom 9 years
Natalie had a pretty sexy role in 'Closer'.
Jillness Jillness 9 years
BOTH! I think they are both bright girls...Scarlett's figure might distract people, but I really think she is just as intellegent as Natalie. Acting wise, I think they are both good. Not amazing, but good.
burke_chi burke_chi 9 years
natalie. scartlett is kinda annoying.
ilanac13 ilanac13 9 years
i have ALWAYS been a natalie fan - i love her. she's usually chosen well on the roles that she takes on - and i think that she has her priorities in line for her life. she's gone to college - worked successfully and stays out of trouble.
MadalenaO MadalenaO 9 years
Definitely Natalie, she is elegant, pretty, talented and smart:) Scarlett, um... I can not understand her popularity.
SugarGirl12 SugarGirl12 9 years
I like both of them but I think I like Natalie a little more
berrymix berrymix 9 years
Natalie. Scarlett is so overrated.
sugajen sugajen 9 years
Natalie is alot of my guy friends crush. Perfect facial features, intelligent, wealthy. Scarlett well at least she has money
Hootie Hootie 9 years
♥ BOTH ♥
coachluvr33 coachluvr33 9 years
I love Natalie. Scarlett irritates me. I agree with gatsby-esque's comment about the big knockers (ha..ha..) I don't think the girl is that attractive and she seems a bit overrated to me. Definitely not good enough for Ryan. No way.
Torquemada Torquemada 9 years
undoubtedly natalie. she's much more graced than that slattern vulgar blonde
sauterhead sauterhead 9 years
Natalie! She's gorgeous, wicked smart, socially conscious, with a sense of humility. Not to mention one of the most talented actors - regardless of age. Scarlett... I think she's beautiful, but I'm not convinced of her talent beyond her looks.
leaglagla leaglagla 9 years
I love them both!!!
moss1080 moss1080 9 years
Natalie is just amazing and not to mention accomplished. I totaly have a girl crush.
buggyslice buggyslice 9 years
creepupmytee creepupmytee 9 years
Scarlett definitely. I love her boobs! ;)
Briandiesel Briandiesel 9 years
I like them both but I think that I would like Natalie better in a conversation.
ElizabethRae ElizabethRae 9 years
Why isn't neither a choice?
laneylaney laneylaney 9 years
I think Scarlett got lucky. She's got a dull, flat acting style that really worked for Lost In Translation, but I don't think she can get beyond it. She seems like a nice enough girl though but I think this is truly where boobs make a difference.... her face is eh.
Mary-Mary Mary-Mary 9 years
I like them both, mostly because they are scandal free and don't court the media. They do their jobs (very well) and go home and try to be normal!
lattegoodness lattegoodness 9 years
Where is the neither button? I don't find Scarlett attractive AT ALL and her bottom teeth bother me. Yes, I have a weird obsession with teeth. And Natalie can be pretty depending on lighting, makeup and angle, but she annoys me with trying to be so "intellectual" and claiming to be against nudity in films, while she was so in "Closer". That movie was horrible anyway.. Please, I'll pass.
Song By Song Movie Trailer
Why Isn't Natalie Portman at the 2017 Oscars?
Natalie Portman Topshop Maternity Dress at Oscars Luncheon
Celebrity Tattoo Pictures
From Our Partners
Latest Celebrity & Entertainment
All the Latest From Ryan Reynolds