Skip Nav
Met Gala
41 Memorable PDA Moments From Met Galas Past
Celebrity PDA
Who Is the Third Wheel Here: Blake Lively, Ryan Reynolds's Mom, or Leslie Jones?
Celebrity Kids
Jennifer Lopez Shares a Ridiculously Cute Moment With Her Twins on Ellen
Around The Web
Join The Conversation
tkb tkb 8 years
mary kate
tkb tkb 8 years
mary kate
0037sammie 0037sammie 9 years
um, anyone notice the jeans?
0037sammie 0037sammie 9 years
um, anyone notice the jeans?
mrskrismendoza mrskrismendoza 9 years
I can't decide is neither for me.
herbiefrog herbiefrog 9 years
...isn't that what is so great about being a twin ? : )))you can never be absolutely surewhich one is doing itwell done babes ))
herbiefrog herbiefrog 9 years
...isn't that what is so great about being a twin ? : ))) you can never be absolutely sure which one is doing it well done babes ))
Pi_Phi1772 Pi_Phi1772 9 years
Weight-wise it looks like Ashley, and she's been seen in those jeans several times.
herbiefrog herbiefrog 9 years
were sll kindof mixed up shhh... see you soon : )
herbiefrog herbiefrog 9 years
were sll kindof mixed upshhh...see you soon : )
herbiefrog herbiefrog 9 years
you guys are funny : ) keep smiling : )) wonder what it must be like to be one half of a twin...
herbiefrog herbiefrog 9 years
you guys are funny : )keep smiling : ))wonder what it must be like to be one half of a twin...
BeautyXRush BeautyXRush 9 years
I cant tell them apart, and I could care less. All I know is one dresses like a bum, more than the other.
K-is-for K-is-for 9 years
I think proper response is "who cares, they both look like sh*t!"
mystery2me mystery2me 9 years
Sugar should always include the "I don't care" option in their polls. You'd get a better idea of what people on this site actually are interested in. Just look at the comments... MK and Ashley get lotsa "I don't cares".
shoegal2280 shoegal2280 9 years
its ashley...she always wears this fendi bag
blob blob 9 years
don't know don't care
blob blob 9 years
don't know don't care
DCStar DCStar 9 years
Pretty darn impossible. On one hand, that handbag seems very Ashley, on the other, the messy hair and black nail polish seems very MK. We may never know!
Briandiesel Briandiesel 9 years
I said Ashley because it looks like a fuller face than MK's ... Also, I think that the bag is more Ashley
mlen mlen 9 years
they look super similar lately- mk has put on a tiny bit of weight and their hair is back to the same color. i need to see them side by side to tell!
ilanac13 ilanac13 9 years
i think it's ashley - there are a few differences in them...and i think that it can't be MK...but i could be wrong.
LolaDub LolaDub 9 years
that is def marykate
LolaDub LolaDub 9 years
that is def marykate
Mary-Kate and Ashley Olsen's Party Style
Mary-Kate and Ashley Olsen Red Carpet Pictures
Mary-Kate Olsen and Olivier Sarkozy's Relationship Facts
Sexiest Woman of 2013 Poll
Sexiest Man of Award Season 2015 | Poll
Shia LaBeouf's New Short Film "Haunted Love" | Video
Jennifer Lawrence Best Moments 2013
Ashley Olsen and Richard Sachs Break Up 2017
Ashley Olsen White Caftan and Jeans in St. Barts Dec. 2016
How Did Mary-Kate Olsen and Olivier Sarkozy Meet?

POPSUGAR, the #1 independent media and technology company for women. Where more than 75 million women go for original, inspirational content that feeds their passions and interests.

From Our Partners
Latest Celebrity & Entertainment
All the Latest From Ryan Reynolds