Brad Pitt [1] might have stopped by The Ellen DeGeneres Show [2] on Friday to talk about his film Once Upon A Time in Hollywood [3], but a different part of their chat has viewers abuzz. Before the longtime friends dove into the box office hit [4], they shared a casual — yet rather surprising — exchange about the origins of their friendship. Reflecting on how they met at Melissa Etheridge's pool party, Brad recalled Ellen hitting on his then-girlfriend. "I was flattered," he added. But, apparently, that wasn't the only time the pair shared a love interest [5]. According to Ellen, they previously dated the same woman, because the Hollywood nexus [6] really is something. Above, watch Brad and Ellen briefly reminisce about their converged paths!