Remember When Carrie Underwood Talked About Her Third Nipple?

Way back in the early 2000s, Carrie Underwood faced Simon Cowell and the rest of the American Idol judges to sing her heart out — and she mentioned a third nipple. Then 21 years old, Carrie blew Simon and Randy Jackson away when she sang "I Can't Make You Love Me," but not before she revealed a few fun facts about herself. Simon asked her (around 1:54 in the video above), "Did you have something you shouldn't have had?" Carrie laughed and got embarrassed, saying, "It looked like a mole. It was a third nipple." She went on to explain why she had it removed, then belted out her audition song before showing off one of her surprising talents: clucking like a chicken. Following news that American Idol has been canceled, get a fun dose of Idol nostalgia with a look at Carrie's audition, then see the cutest pictures of Carrie and Mike Fisher!