Skip Nav
Shirtless
Shirtless Leonardo DiCaprio Serves Poolside Glamour With Kate Winslet in St.-Tropez
The Royals
15 Pictures That Prove Kate and Camilla Cannot Contain Their Laughter Around Each Other
The Royals
10 Times Princess Diana Was the Most Badass Member of the British Royal Family
Join The Conversation
lanilovespeaches lanilovespeaches 10 years
yeah not really a big fan of hers at all, definitely not after this
SexualSuspect SexualSuspect 10 years
but thats the thing "Scottdavis" it's not that it just happened "This one time", it happeneds alot again, walk in the TRL/MTV studios and just ask the crew members about her, they will tell you shes a BITCH to all the "little people"....the whole innocent, goody goody, i love all the children of the world is an act, which is pretty ironic since the girl CAN'T ACT
scottdavis0676 scottdavis0676 10 years
For all the people that are so fickle as to turn on her over an "alleged" incident, good riddance. She doesn't need wishy-washy fans like you in the first place! I'm actually pococuratne in regards to Hilary, but that is besides the point. I just don't buy into the notion that her not signing autographs one time is emblematic of her personality, or that it somehow makes her a bad person. I am going to give her a pass on this, because I believe this to be an abberation. If it becomes a leitmotif, then maybe I'll have a change of heart. Get over it!
SassAndBide SassAndBide 10 years
it takes like less than a second to scribble ur name down. shes gonna lose her young fans soon if she keeps acting bitchy like this. i dunno why anyone likes her, they think shes a goody goody and a role model.whatever
Wicked Wicked 10 years
It says in the article that they girls asked for autographs as she was exiting the restaurant. I don;'t see why she couldn't have done it. It would only take 3 seconds.
SexualSuspect SexualSuspect 10 years
not Surprise the girl is a totaly BITCH! ask anyone in the industry, tell will tell u she is a fake. just go into TRL and ask the camera crew..they will all tell you how badly she treats everyone. She sucks! GET UR TEETH FIXED HORSE!
tshellyedwards tshellyedwards 10 years
Well - okay, what do I say? I LOVE Hil, and I can understand how her not signing a fan's napkin (or whatever it was) could be looked at as mean, rude, selfish, etc. BUT - who knows how she said it? Maybe she said it very politely... I mean, I can't imagine being that famous and CONSTANTLY being interrupted, with no one respecting my privacy. That would be really hard. So - if this is true - I'm giving her the benefit of the doubt that she said it in a very tactful, appropriate way. Nuff said.
cfeccentric cfeccentric 10 years
It seems like autographs wouldn't be that big of a deal, but whatever. She was with her family, so I guess she has a decent excuse.
phatE phatE 10 years
thank you! a voice of reason!
herjoiedevivre herjoiedevivre 10 years
if this one tiny incident is enough to make people change their viewpoints on hilary duff, then yall really haven't considered how many mistakes you've made in your own lives that I'm sure are much bigger than this. I for one can name at least three horrible things I've done that are much worse than this, and at least three people who have stuck by me through those horrible things. A lot of you are overreacting in my opinion. I can understand why she didn't want to sign- first of all, coming up to a starlet in the middle of dinner is just rude. If they weren't old enough to realize that, their parents definitely should've. And secondly, for a while, maybe she didn't want to be "Hilary Duff", maybe she just wanted to be a kid out with her family. sure, it wouldn't have taken that much time to sign, but this is not a big deal. hellooo, lindsay lohan just got arrested for her second dui. now THAt's a big deal.
phatE phatE 10 years
it would so suck to be in her shoes with the standards you guys set for her..
BonjourChaton BonjourChaton 10 years
Conanho I totally agree with you, the poor dear, having to sign an autograph, I don't know how she goes on!
jaan_black jaan_black 10 years
I'd understand if it was a grown man or woman but you ALWAYS sign for kids...somebody get her back to the stable, quick!
phatE phatE 10 years
babyballerina, it's not like she never signs them.. it's one time and she got blasted, who knows why she didn't do it, but if it would have been malicious on her part, she wouldn't have said sorry i with my family, and i never get to see them. it sounds to me like she's trying to set boundaries and probably feeling overwhelmed. its lame when people say oh well they are her fans, they are the reason she makes the money, yada yada. that is 100% true, but they are NOT entitled to her life at all times.. most people make money because of other people investing in their product. with the unrealistic standards some of you set, no wonder LL and britney have lost it.
baby-ballerina baby-ballerina 10 years
i don't see how signing a few autographs, would be such a hard thing to do. the fans are half the reason they're there.
Cinnamon-Girl Cinnamon-Girl 10 years
I don`t blame her , she looks cute here btw ..love the outfit.
phatE phatE 10 years
all of you who have let this change your view on her are ridiculous. get your freakin head out of the clouds NEWS FLASH: SHE'S HUMAN!! what you expect from celebrities is unrealistic. popsugar, yes, even hilary has an off day because she's an actual person, just like the rest of us. if you blame her for wanting to eat dinner with her family then that's your own deal.. she gets asked for autographs 24/7 she is aloud to say NO. this entire article is based on what a spy saw.. people need to get an effing life, she deals with enough crap being in the spotlight, let her eat dinner with her family in po-dunk richmond texas. ugh!
krisua krisua 10 years
Well I can only imagine how much time it takes.
lovekailua lovekailua 10 years
they definitely have to set limits....I agree with everything Jillness has said. I just think it is funny some people now 'hate her" (or whatever not a fan now) because of one incident in the ny daily news! lmao.
Jillness Jillness 10 years
One more thing... Isn't she from Texas? It is very possible she was having dinner with extended family that she rarely gets to see. How many times do you think she has tried to have a dinner with her family, and focus on them only to be bombarded with autograph seekers that take up all of your time? One can quickly turn into hundreds, and that takes a lot of time if you aren't going to turn everyone down. Sometimes you have to set limits, and stick to those. If you don't, they take from you until you have neglected your own life and relationships...just for the approval of strangers. Stars are people to, and they have every right to take 1 night off.
angeldevilwings angeldevilwings 10 years
Everyone is entitled to be a bitch a few times in life.
desertbanshee desertbanshee 10 years
When I was young, I begged my dad to go ask Jimmie Walker for his autograph - he was on "Good Times" - and even though my dad didn't want to, he did it for me anyway. Well, Jimmy said no, my dad was furious, and I never watched that show again. Do you think that's why it got cancelled? I know a kid thinks it's a really big deal to see Hilary. They think she's pretty, buy her movies and music. Now those girls know the truth... it's all just a $business$ illusion.
sweetrae80 sweetrae80 10 years
I still like her but I don't think she is as sweet as we have been lead to believe....and why is she going to Hyde? She's not even 21!
JaimeLeah526 JaimeLeah526 10 years
She seems like she's turning in the wrong direction and starting to try and become a bad girl. I hate that. I want the sweet Hil we know and love back. How hard is it to write your name on a poster??
lem0n lem0n 10 years
Some of the comments here say that it wouldn't be a big deal to to take a few minutes out to sign a piece of paper, and i can see how we would feel that way. But a few minutes for lots of people all the time can wear thin. It might have just been a bad time to ask. She seems like a nice girl and people who have met her commented that thought she was nice too. Let's not hold one "story" against her.
Hilary Duff's Home Gets Burglarized After She Shares Vacation Photos
Hilary Duff's Photo of Luca on His Birthday March 2017
Hilary Duff Solid and Striped Gingham Swimsuit
Hilary Duff Through the Years | Pictures
From Our Partners
Latest Celebrity & Entertainment
All the Latest From Ryan Reynolds