When we heard Netflix was releasing a gay holiday rom-com [1] this year, it was already our favorite. It has everything you'd expect: a snowy small town, a wholesome family, a big-city visitor on a quest for love, and festive decor galore.

Jennifer Coolidge [2], Kathy Najimy, and Jennifer Robertson need not debate who the biggest icon in the film is. Instead, they sit down with us along with their fellow stars [3] Michael Urie and Philemon Chambers [4] to share just how they trim their trees each year.

'Tis the reason to watch with your bestie, especially if they need dating advice. Single All the Way [5] premieres on Netflix on Dec. 2.