Just because American Horror Story [1] is the scariest show around, it doesn't mean the cast can't let loose. Last Friday, Evan Peters, Denis O'Hare, and Finn Wittrock stopped by Universal Studios Hollywood to kick off Halloween [2] Horror Nights. Of course, the group had to check out the AHS-themed haunted house, which highlighted many terrifying moments from the show [3]'s previous seasons. And, well, let's just say they had trouble holding it together. We've collected our favorite pictures and captioned them with the likely thoughts of each star.
Denis O'Hare: "Ah, yes. Now I can finally be myself."
Finn Wittrock: "I should not have done this."
Evan Peters: "Nope."
Guy in the Background: "Holy sh*t, can I have a selfie?"
Denis O'Hare: "I'm just saying, I thought it would be scarier."
Finn Wittrock: "This looks just like my teddy bear!"
![Evan Peters: [Screaming]
Denis O'Hare: "Oh sh*t! LOL!"
Finn Wittrock: "Release me from this prison."](https://media1.popsugar-assets.com/files/thumbor/B5eFgXUUGLaTWFvaGn9bmK3OjrQ/fit-in/1024x1024/filters:format_auto-!!-:strip_icc-!!-/2016/09/19/934/n/1922283/45f68edc5579b857_GettyImages-606999702/i/Evan-Peters-ScreamingDenis-OHare-Oh-sht.jpg "Evan Peters: [Screaming]
Denis O'Hare: \"Oh sh*t! LOL!\"
Finn Wittrock: \"Release me from this prison.\"")
Evan Peters: [Screaming]
Denis O'Hare: "Oh sh*t! LOL!"
Finn Wittrock: "Release me from this prison."
![Finn Wittrock: [Squealing]
Evan Peters: "Yikes, though."
Denis O'Hare: "What is that, Knotty Pine?"](https://media1.popsugar-assets.com/files/thumbor/k5wHe7j1aNZhfEqvMToL0ppnXzw/fit-in/1024x1024/filters:format_auto-!!-:strip_icc-!!-/2016/09/19/934/n/1922283/e6795b4af1a52e77_GettyImages-606999368/i/Finn-Wittrock-SquealingEvan-Peters-Yikes-though.jpg "Finn Wittrock: [Squealing]
Evan Peters: \"Yikes, though.\"
Denis O'Hare: \"What is that, Knotty Pine?\"")
Finn Wittrock: [Squealing]
Evan Peters: "Yikes, though."
Denis O'Hare: "What is that, Knotty Pine?"
![Evan Peters: [Shrieking]
Finn Wittrock: "JungleJim4322@yahoo.com? Is that you?"
Denis O'Hare: "This is cute, but where's the exit?"](https://media1.popsugar-assets.com/files/thumbor/KesEspQxYy6xksJuYJrYL_9dqXA/fit-in/1024x1024/filters:format_auto-!!-:strip_icc-!!-/2016/09/19/934/n/1922283/ec56373ab8663f0b_GettyImages-606999482/i/Evan-Peters-ShriekingFinn-Wittrock-JungleJim4322yahoocom.jpg "Evan Peters: [Shrieking]
Finn Wittrock: \"JungleJim4322@yahoo.com? Is that you?\"
Denis O'Hare: \"This is cute, but where's the exit?\"")
Evan Peters: [Shrieking]
Finn Wittrock: "JungleJim4322@yahoo.com? Is that you?"
Denis O'Hare: "This is cute, but where's the exit?"
Finn Wittrock: "PLEASE DON'T EAT ME."
Denis O'Hare: "Oh nooo."
Evan Peters: "Bruh."
Denis O'Hare: "I will slap you."
Twisty: "OMG no, please, I was just kidding. Have mercy?"
Denis O'Hare: "Oh hey, long time!"
Evan Peters: "How you been? Miss you."
Finn Wittrock: "Who even is this?"
Denis O'Hare: "Oh man, what a gas."
Finn Wittrock: "Please just let it end."
Finn Wittrock: "Man, am I glad that's over. So many heart attacks."
Denis O'Hare: "Oh, don't be so dramatic."
Evan Peters: "Um, you had a heart attack?"
Finn Wittrock: "Never again."
Denis O'Hare: "Aw, c'mon. It was great."
Evan Peters: "I miss that rubber suit."