Skip Nav
New on Netflix in October: 45 New Titles, Including Stranger Things Season 2!
Fall TV
Stranger Things Age Investigation: How Old Are the Kids in the Cast?
Award Season
Didn't Watch Big Little Lies? Here Are All the Places You Can Catch It Now

American Idol: The First Four Say Farewell

Things sure do move fast in these early voting rounds of American Idol. Just like that, we're down to 20. The first elimination took place Thursday night, and I can't say I was shocked at any of the contestants who were dismissed. Who's gone? For that, you're going to have to


Joanne Borgella and Amy Davis were the first to go from the girls' half of the draw, while Colton Berry and Garrett Haley said goodbye from the guys' side. I can't say I'm terribly surprised about any of the four; I even picked all but Colton to go home. (How did you do? Be sure to check your guys' ballot and your girls' ballot.) Colton should stick with the musical theater, I think, and Joanne could definitely have a singing career; I think she just had a really off night. The other two? I'd be surprised if they turn up again, but stranger things have happened in the Idol universe. What do you think? Did voters make the right call?

Here are a few of my other thoughts on Thursday's results show:

  • I love the group sings. So shoot me, I really do. They provide such wonderful, awkward moments, like David A. utterly outsinging Garrett and Kristy Lee and Luke teaming for a "hmm, does this mean they're going home?" duet at the center of the stage.
  • Also awkward: Colton's hair. I really do kind of love that kid, though.
  • Garrett got kicked off so fast, I don't know that anyone had time to process what was coming. That made it a dead giveaway that Kristy Lee wasn't going home, though; Seacrest never does the same trick twice.
  • Amy Davis' departure = the decline of the influence of Vote for the Worst? Discuss.
  • Simon's response when Seacrest asked what he was thinking as he sipped out of his cup: "How much I love Coca Cola." Wow, that was almost some 30 Rock-level product placement.
  • Love Joanne's "Sunday — I mean, uh, Wednesday — was a crazy day" slip-up. So they pretaped the shows this week. Who cares? Don't make these stressed-out singers lie, too!
  • Wow, Chikezie really thought he was going home, didn't he?
  • While I'm sure it's nice to have your family there after you've just been kicked off American Idol, the constant panning shots to sad relatives were a bit much.

Your thoughts? Ready for another round next week? We'll be down to 12 before we know it!

Photos courtesy of Fox

Join The Conversation
jflutterjess jflutterjess 9 years
I predicted the girls were going home. Amy is awful. I don't even know how she made it to the Top 24.
Rydia Rydia 9 years
LaurenG22-So true! I am with you on that one. Each guy that sang I was shocked because I thought Josiah was better. Did you see his video for the other song he wrote...the one about a ship sinking?? So good!
vcastellanos16 vcastellanos16 9 years
I love David A.! he is so good! also, I enjoy listening to the guy with dreadlocks. (what's his name?) I really don't think that the girls are good enough this year.
coachluvr33 coachluvr33 9 years
I totally agree with LaurenG22 about Josiah. I loved him!! I didn't even watch it this week. I watched 1/2 of the guys and then none of the girls or the elimination. I just don't agree with some of their choices. I think a guy will win though.
x_juicyfruit x_juicyfruit 9 years
I predicted everyone who left, would leave. Their performances weren't great compared to the rest of the competition, and really not that great just on their own. They were the weakest ones.
bchicgrl bchicgrl 9 years
I'm glad Amy, Colton and Garrett were sent home, the 3 of them couldn't really sing all that well. I think Joann was robbed, I can't stand that Amanda chick, she is awful. I hope she goes soon cause I don't think I can deal with much more screeching from her and it's only the 1st week. *sigh*
laneylaney laneylaney 9 years
Oh no! I liked Joanne's personality a lot and I wanted to see what she could do.
Linda-McP Linda-McP 9 years
I'm not really impressed by many of the guys--or the girls, for that matter. Hopefully the real stars will emerge soon.
LaurenG22 LaurenG22 9 years
I still can't believe either one of those guys made it in the first place, ESPECIALLY over JOSIAH!?!!?! This competition is weird.
lily8206 lily8206 9 years
I got them all right except for Joanne Borgella. It's hard to have a really solid opinion because over-all I'm not that impressed with this years bunch. No one sticks out for me. I'm glad Colton is off the show though. Man, I found him annoying!
When Is American Idol Coming Back?
From Our Partners
Latest Entertainment
All the Latest From Ryan Reynolds