Skip Nav
Spring
31 of the Best New Books You Should Read This Spring
Black Panther
Which Black Panther Character Are You?
Oscars
Fill Out Our Oscar Ballot For a Chance to Win $1,000!

American Idol New Judges

American Idol: Are You Happy With the New Judges' Panel?

Several months and dozens of rumors after American Idol began its search to replace judges Steven Tyler and Jennifer Lopez, the show finally has a new panel. Keith Urban has officially been announced as the last piece of the panel puzzle, joined by previously announced Mariah Carey and Nicki Minaj. Randy Jackson is also sticking around, making an expanded panel of four judges — plus veteran host Ryan Seacrest, of course.

As a longtime fan of American Idol, this panel feels so far from where the show started, and it kind of makes me feel homesick for the days of Paula and Simon. While I respect Carey as an artist, I don't know if she or Minaj will be interesting enough to watch. I actually think Keith Urban might be the biggest asset, given his recent experience on Australia's version of The Voice, but the strange combination of all these very different musicians seems like a tired plea for a more varied audience. We'll find out how they work together come January when the new season premieres, but what do you think?

Image Source: Fox
Mariah Carey's All I Want For Christmas Hits Billboard Chart
Mariah Carey Christmas Pictures
Mariah Carey Steals Meryl Streep's Seat at Golden Globes
Mariah Carey Family Christmas Pictures
Mariah Carey New Year's Eve Performance 2018
Best "All I Want For Christmas Is You" Covers
Meryl Streep Talks About Mariah Carey Stealing Her Seat
Mariah Carey's "All I Want For Christmas" in a Minor Key
Mariah Carey Performing on New Year's Eve 2018
Mariah Carey at the 2018 Golden Globe Awards
From Our Partners
Latest Entertainment
All the Latest From Ryan Reynolds