Skip Nav
Fall Movie Preview: 45 Movies You Need to Know About This Fall
Hot Damn, Netflix Has an AMAZING Selection of Horror Movies Right Now
Grey's Anatomy
4 Times Grey's Anatomy Has Used "The Tumor Plot"

Book Review: The Girls' Guide to Hunting and Fishing

Book Review: The Girls' Guide to Hunting and Fishing

I'm excited about a lot of the movies premiering at this year's Tribeca Film Festival, and Suburban Girl is near the top of my list. It's based on two of the short stories from Melissa Bank's collection The Girls' Guide to Hunting and Fishing, which was one of my favorite books when it came out in 1999. It had been a while since I'd read the book, so with the movie looming, I decided to drag my old paperback off the shelf and see if the book still holds up.

And it does. Bank's books (she also wrote The Wonder Spot) are great examples of what I like to call "upscale chick lit" — well-written stories with central female characters who are intelligent, witty and unafraid to speak their minds. In Girls' Guide, the focus is Jane Rosenal, whom we first meet as a 14-year-old realizing, as she watches her brother's relationship with his girlfriend slowly disintegrate, that the quest for true love really sucks.

Jane never stops looking for love, but as she grows older she also starts trying to piece together the other components of a fulfilling life. Those interests intersect fiercely in the two stories on which Suburban Girl is based, so

"My Old Man" and "The Worst Thing a Suburban Girl Could Imagine" show Jane at her conflicted and endearing best. She's in her 20s, trying to succeed in publishing, when she meets Archie Knox, a powerful executive at a rival firm. She's drawn to him, but in a matter-of-fact way; there's no hearts-and-flowers romance, just a series of dinner meetings and sudden advances. Not even half his age, she longs to impress him, to be the sharp, brilliant woman he's been looking for. "I stored up stories to tell him," Jane says at one point. "I practiced them in my head." She wants to hold her own with him, but at every turn, he gives her a new challenge — his alcoholism, his playboy past, his unexpected difficulties in bed.

In the second of the stories, "The Worst Thing a Suburban Girl Could Imagine," the Archie story dovetails with that of the other important man in Jane's life: her father. After a brief breakup, Jane is back with Archie, much to her family's disappointment, and she's also in the process of choosing to ruin her career rather than please her boss, a sort of Miranda Priestly-lite. Then she finds out her father is dying of leukemia, which snaps everything into perspective — but not in the way you'd imagine. I've reread that story several times now, and there are a few lines that always give me chills.

I'm glad the movie zeroed in on those two stories; they have a coherent arc, and they show off the strongest parts of Jane (called Brett in the movie) as a character. But the other stories in Girls' Guide are also worth a read, including the hilarious final chapter in which Jane decides to abandon her natural sarcasm and try out the dating techniques in a book called How to Meet and Marry Mr. Right. She imagines the authors perched on her shoulder, telling her when to talk and what to say ("Keep him guessing!" "Let him pay!"). In the end, of course, she figures out it's all ridiculous, and she leaves us with a pure, simple revelation that sums up Jane's whole story: "I realize that I can say whatever I want now. And I do."


Daylyn Daylyn 10 years
You guys have me intrigued, I might have to pick up this book! :)
jadenirvana jadenirvana 10 years
Ooh actually its Sarah Jessica Parker for "Love Walked In" Here's the details, if anyone's interested
jadenirvana jadenirvana 10 years
Thanks Sarasmile, that's so interesting because I heard Reese Witherspoon had also optioned "Love Walked in" Maria de Santos, another amazing thinking-chick-lit book. I will check out that short story collection too...
Entertainment Entertainment 10 years
jadenirvana, you just gave me a great idea for a Buzzworthy Challenge! Check back on Sunday for the details
StefaPie StefaPie 10 years
This book is what i call the start of my grown-up life. I read it when i was 14 (i'm 22), and it was amazing. It became okay to be the funny, weird, smart girl. To this day lines from it will pop into my head, especially parts of "You Could Be Anyone", which is my favorite of the stories, and the first story with teenage Jane is awesome, i liked her standards. It is my go-to teenage girl gift, funny and sad and more realistic than most other "chick lit". I've been a little worried about the adaptation, but i trust SMG.
SaraSmile SaraSmile 10 years
I looooove this book. I am a little apprehensive about the movie, especially now since reading that they are changing her name. I am from the Philly suburbs, and so is Jane (and I guess Melissa Bank), so I hope they dont change that detail. The Wonder Spot was good, but sadder than TGGTH&F, and a little too similar in characterization and plot. A really excellent short story collection that straddles chick lit and more mainstream genres is How to Breathe Underwater by Julie Orringer. jadenirvana - I think Reese Witherspoon actually has optioned the rights to London is the Best City in America. FYI!
kendallina kendallina 10 years
I didn't know Suburban Girl was based on this book, which I read as a teen and loved.
jadenirvana jadenirvana 10 years
This is one of my favorite books of all time, perfectly fitting into that elusive "Thinking Girl's Chick Lit" category. Does anyone else recommend any books that fit into this category? I've heard Laura Dave's "London is the Best City in America" is such a book, but I haven't read it myself. Have you guys?
wiggy wiggy 10 years
i love this book too. i remember when it first came out my best friend and i read it then wondered who'd we cast as jane if there ever was a movie. we both wanted reese witherspoon. but i think sarah michelle will do a good job. i'm excited to see the movie!
Candybee Candybee 10 years
I LOVED this book! I can't wait to see Suburban Girl. In fact, I think I will dig out this book and read it again!
What Is an Advance Team in Politics?
Best Books of 2016
From Our Partners
Latest Entertainment
All the Latest From Ryan Reynolds