Skip Nav
Stranger Things
Stranger Things Season 2: Everything We Know
Mindhunter: Your New Netflix Obsession Has (Terrifying) Roots in Reality
8 Reasons Scream Is the Ultimate Scary Movie

Caption It!

Welcome to the Caption It game on BuzzSugar! Every Wednesday, I'll post a photo still from a TV show or movie here and challenge you to think of the most hilarious caption possible. I'll announce the finalists the following Tuesday, and you'll get to vote for the best caption!

Another week, another condom-related Caption It challenge. In the poll for last week's photo from I Love You, Beth Cooper, misshouston is winning with this caption:

"Heyyy, guys, I brought condoms for everybo—whoa! I think we may have to share..."

Ha! That one cracked me up as well. Congrats, misshouston. Now for this week's challenge with the ever-handsome Michael Vartan in TNT's HawthoRNe:

I could totally go for one of those muffins right now. Anyway, leave your captions in the comment space below before 5 p.m. PDT on Monday, July 20 to be considered for a spot in the voting round. Have fun!

Photo courtesy of TNT

JohnW JohnW 8 years
daise daise 8 years
Woman: Back away from my muffins vanilla Michael: You know what, you ARE a nazi! Director: CUT! Wrong show Vartan! What d'you think this is? An episode of Grey's Anatomy?
JohnW JohnW 8 years
AlphaChickee AlphaChickee 8 years
"Suuuure, blame it on the poppyseeds in the muffins..."
kafarine-tin-tin kafarine-tin-tin 8 years
So, his life got flipped, then turned upside down?
RyanRachelFan RyanRachelFan 8 years
Him thinking: Is that a piece of blueberry muffin on her upper lip? Maybe if I stare intensely at it, it will go away. Hmm... maybe I will have a muffin after all. That piece on her lip, does look delicious. Wait, could it be? Is it raspberry? I wonder if she´ll notice if I swap it off her lip with my tongue... Her saying: HEY! Are you even listening to a word I´m saying?!?
Symphonee Symphonee 8 years
You are too small to be the muffin nazi. Step aside
Symphonee Symphonee 8 years
You always seemed so much taller in the Matrix
luv2blazy luv2blazy 8 years
So, it's okay for a guy to have a muffin top, but not a girl?
JulieJean JulieJean 8 years
Man, how I wish Alias hadn't ended...
"muff-in huh, OK, but how about a butter turn-over afterwards" ?
halfbakedjake halfbakedjake 8 years
C'mon doesn't have to be like this.....put down the carb patty and just walk away....
kismekate kismekate 8 years
I'm going to stare at you awkwardly until you pass me a muffin...
Chrstne Chrstne 8 years
"Well, I see the only time you diet is when you're not cruisin' by for some muffins..."
Dana18 Dana18 8 years
" Can I buy you a cup of coffee with out you going all crazy on me!"
Dana18 Dana18 8 years
" I've been wanting to ask you this for a long time, will you pass my that blueberry muffin."
From Our Partners
Latest Entertainment
All the Latest From Ryan Reynolds