Skip Nav
Love It. Save Your Favorites Now.
Buzz Readers Cast The Great Gatsby
American Horror Story All Seasons Timeline
American Horror Story
A Timeline of Every Single Important Date in the American Horror Story Universe
Reactions to Robin Williams Documentary Come Inside My Mind
Robin Williams
The World Is in a Puddle of Tears After Watching the Robin Williams Documentary
The Crown Season 3 Pictures
the crown
Meet the New Royals! The Crown Releases the First Images For Season 3
View On One Page
ADVERTISEMENT ()
Start Slideshow

We were pumped about yesterday's rumblings regarding Baz Luhrmann's remake of The Great Gatsby. Rumor is Leonardo DiCaprio, Tobey Maguire, and Rebecca Hall are being considered for the roles of Jay, Nick, and Daisy, but you actually have some casting ideas of your own. Several of the comments suggested potential Hollywood replacements for the trio of characters (and actress picks for Jordan), so here are the stars you'd like to see in the parts.

Ryan Gosling as Jay Gatsby
Joseph Gordon-Levitt as Nick Carraway
Amanda Seyfried as Daisy Buchanan
Ellen Page as Jordan Baker
Honorable Mentions
Start Slideshow
Join the conversation
From Our Partners
Britney Spears Talks About Mickey Mouse Club Reunion
Disney
Britney Spears Is "Definitely" Up For a Mickey Mouse Club Reunion, and Someone Please Make It Happen
by Morgane Le Caer
Once Upon a Time in Hollywood Movie Details
Once Upon a Time in Hollywood
Leonardo DiCaprio Shares a Very Retro First Look at Once Upon a Time in Hollywood
by Quinn Keaney
Andrew Garfield's Acceptance Speech at 2018 Tony Awards
Andrew Garfield
Andrew Garfield's Impassioned Tonys Speech About the LGBTQ+ Community Will Make You Tear Up
by Kelsie Gibson
Ryan Gosling and Jimmy Kimmel Go to Space Video 2018
Ryan Gosling
Ryan Gosling and Jimmy Kimmel Tried Being Astronauts Together — We Can't Stop Giggling
by Karenna Meredith
Ryan Gosling's Kids Won't Let Him Watch TV
Ryan Gosling
Ryan Gosling Isn't Watching Much TV These Days, Unless There's a "Talking Tiger" Involved
by Karenna Meredith
First Man Trailer
Ryan Gosling
Ryan Gosling Shoots For the Moon in the Trailer For Damien Chazelle's First Man
by Quinn Keaney
Once Upon a Time in Hollywood Cast
Once Upon a Time in Hollywood
Once Upon a Time in Hollywood: the Full Cast For Quentin Tarantino's Manson Movie
by Quinn Keaney
Who Will Play Willy Wonka in the Reboot?
Nostalgia
Donald Glover! Ryan Gosling! The Willy Wonka Remake Could Actually Be Good
by Kelsey Garcia
Gwyneth Paltrow's Comments on Brad Pitt and Harvey Weinstein
Celebrity Interviews
Gwyneth Paltrow Recalls How Grateful She Was to Brad Pitt For Standing Up to Harvey Weinstein
by Erin Cullum
Cameos in Deadpool 2
Deadpool 2
12 Blink-and-You'll-Miss-Them Cameos in Deadpool 2
by Quinn Keaney
Who Does Brad Pitt Play in Deadpool 2?
Brad Pitt
Of All the Wild Cameos in Deadpool 2, THIS Was the Best (and Most Shocking)
by Ryan Roschke
Emma Stone and Andrew Garfield at the 2018 Met Gala
Met Gala
Emma Stone Avoids a Potentially Awkward Run-In With Andrew Garfield at the Met Gala
by Terry Carter
From Our Partners
Latest Entertainment
We're Hiring! Write For Us About Us Advertising Contact FAQ Archives
Power Your Happy Beauty by POPSUGAR POPSUGAR Must Have POPSUGAR Insights
Terms Privacy Policy
©2018 PopSugar • POPSUGAR Entertainment & Culture
All the Latest From Ryan Reynolds