Skip Nav
Love It. Save Your Favorites Now.
Buzz Readers Cast The Great Gatsby
Salem the Cat on Sabrina Netflix Red Carpet Photos 2018
Cats
Salem the Cat Showed Up to the Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Red Carpet, So Yeah, I'm Deceased
She's All That Quotes Quiz
Nostalgia
Only '90s Kids Will Ace This She's All That Quotable Quotes Quiz
Annabelle 3 Movie Details
Movies
Oh, Great — There's a Third Annabelle Movie Bringing Us a Fresh Batch of Nightmares
Reactions to Shirtless Chidi Adagonye on The Good Place
Eye Candy
The Good Place: We Learn What Eleanor Knew All Along — Chidi Is Seriously Jacked!
The Curse of La Llorona Trailer
Movie Trailers
Prepare Yourself: The Curse of La Llorona Trailer Is 2 Minutes of Pure Fear
View On One Page
ADVERTISEMENT ()
Start Slideshow

We were pumped about yesterday's rumblings regarding Baz Luhrmann's remake of The Great Gatsby. Rumor is Leonardo DiCaprio, Tobey Maguire, and Rebecca Hall are being considered for the roles of Jay, Nick, and Daisy, but you actually have some casting ideas of your own. Several of the comments suggested potential Hollywood replacements for the trio of characters (and actress picks for Jordan), so here are the stars you'd like to see in the parts.

Ryan Gosling as Jay Gatsby
Joseph Gordon-Levitt as Nick Carraway
Amanda Seyfried as Daisy Buchanan
Ellen Page as Jordan Baker
Honorable Mentions
Start Slideshow
Join the conversation
From Our Partners
Ryan Gosling and Damien Chazelle Photos
Ryan Gosling
Name Something More Pure Than Ryan Gosling and Damien Chazelle's Friendship, We'll Wait
by Lucy Kenny
Britney Spears and Ryan Gosling on Ellen 2018
The Ellen DeGeneres Show
Britney Spears and Ryan Gosling Had a Mickey Mouse Club Reunion, and Where's JT?!
by Laura Marie Meyers
Ryan Gosling on First Man and His Kids on Jimmy Kimmel
Ryan Gosling
Ryan Gosling’s 4-Year-Old Thinks He Works on the Moon Because of His Latest Role, and LOL
by Alessia Santoro
Michelle Williams Venom Movie Interview Sept. 2018
Michelle Williams
How Michelle Williams Deals With Her Own Anxiety
by Ryan Roschke
Michelle Williams Wedding Ring
Michelle Williams
1 Look at Michelle Williams's Wedding Band, and You'll Be Searching For a Duplicate
by Erin Cullum
Charlie's Angels Reboot Cast
Charlie's Angels
Noah Centineo Has Joined the Charlie's Angels Reboot — See Who Else Is in the Cast
by Mekishana Pierre
Michelle Williams Busy Philipps Quotes About Each Other
Michelle Williams
9 Sweet Things Busy Philipps and Michelle Williams Have Said About Their Friendship
by Hedy Phillips
Ryan Gosling Promoting First Man Pictures
Ryan Gosling
Need a Little Pick Me Up? Here Are 90 Photos of Ryan Gosling Being His Beautiful Self
by Morgane Le Caer
Michelle Williams and Phil Elverum Pictures Sept. 2018
Michelle Williams
Michelle Williams Is the Picture of Wedded Bliss While Antique Shopping With Her New Husband
by Britt Stephens
Ryan Gosling Visits a Coffee Shop in Toronto September 2018
Ryan Gosling
This Cute Story Is Further Proof That Ryan Gosling Is One of the Nicest Guys in Hollywood
by Gemma Cartwright
Best Pictures From the Venice Film Festival 2018
Lady Gaga
Ciao, Bella! See the Most Glamorous Photos From the Venice Film Festival
by Britt Stephens
Ryan Gosling Black-and-White Pictures
Ryan Gosling
The Definition of Dapper? Ryan Gosling in Black-and-White Photographs
by Lucy Kenny
From Our Partners
Latest Entertainment
We're Hiring! Write For Us About Us Advertising Contact FAQ Archives
Power Your Happy POPSUGAR at Kohl's Collection Beauty by POPSUGAR POPSUGAR Must Have POPSUGAR Insights
Terms Privacy Policy
©2018 PopSugar • POPSUGAR Entertainment & Culture
All the Latest From Ryan Reynolds