Skip Nav
New on Netflix in October: 45 New Titles, Including Stranger Things Season 2!
These 46 New Titles Coming to Netflix in November Will Help You Survive Thanksgiving
Emilia Clarke
Star Wars: Everything We Know About the Han Solo Spinoff Movie (Including the Title!)

Haley Reinhart Voted off American Idol

Was the Right Contestant Voted Off American Idol?

Well, there you have it: our two American Idol finalists. Haley was voted off tonight, clearing the way for Scotty McCreery and Lauren Alaina to go head-to-head in the final next week to win it all. After some tearful hometown visits, Ryan Seacrest announced Haley as the contestant voted off.

I'm kind of surprised, since Haley got such good feedback from the judges, but America has spoken, and Haley has been eliminated. What do you think of the results — do you think Haley was the right person to go, or should Scotty or Lauren have gotten kicked off so Haley could be in the final two?

Photo courtesy of Fox

Natassja88 Natassja88 6 years
Haley was the best she had the best voice it was different from everyone it should of been Haley Casey and James in the finially three I so pissed and lot of other ppl are to that makes me think this thing is rigged
TheEnchantedOne TheEnchantedOne 6 years
I really liked her when she sang Adele's Rolling In The Deep and The Animals' House Of The Rising Sun. But her other performances didn't really do much for me. I didn't like her attitude that one time when the judges gave her some not-so favorable comments. Her bearing really turned me off. She's not even an established artist yet. What more then? A little humility truly goes a long way. People can't always give her positive critiques. She could at least be accepting of the constructive criticisms thrown her way. She joined a competition, she should've expected that.
ski2006 ski2006 6 years
Hailey is a good singer but not good enough. She is a bitch and it's obvious she thought she was going to win. She did not show compassion for any of the other contestants when they left. She made a rude comment to her fan when she went home. She thinks she is much cuter than she is. I wish she had left weeks ago. I work in the entertainment industry and don't see her going far. Don't expect to see much of her anymore...
JaeLa JaeLa 6 years
Halley's attitude last night was clearly childish and extremely unprofessional. Her last preformance lacked class & integrity. Yes, can she sign....but it takes the whole package. It this business you have to have it cannot have the attitude that you are cannot wear your poor attitude on your shoulder! They will chew you up & spit you out! Before she would be signed to my label she would have to do a clear 180....she's good but not breathtakingly good......Halley, baby work on that attitude. Hopefully you haven't ended your career before you even got started before of your "poor performance" after America voted last night.
Burkina Burkina 6 years
No fangirl here. I don't care much for Lauren or Scotty but they do really well in their lane and that is what being an artist is about. Not how many genres you can cram on your list. Haley is like Lady Gaga. With all the theatrics for a moment you think wow this girl is an original. But strip away all the nonsense yelling and voice cackling and you don't have much. You'd be surprised how much a raspy voice can mask.
New American Idol Judges 2018
When Is American Idol Coming Back?
From Our Partners
Latest Entertainment
All the Latest From Ryan Reynolds