This was the year of Channing Tatum, and his first big role in 2012 was in this romantic drama. The movie is beyond cheesy and sappy, but who cares? Who didn't fall for Leo, the kind of boyfriend who brings you cold remedies in the rain? The fact that Paige (Rachel McAdams) doesn't remember she ever loved this dreamboat is one of the great movie mysteries of the year.
— Shannon Vestal, associate editor