Skip Nav
Award Season
6 Moments That Made the Emmys Worth Watching
Over 50 Romantic Country Songs For Your First Dance
Best of 2017
24 Beloved Shows That Are Ending in 2017

Katie Stevens and Andrew Garcia Voted Off American Idol

Were the Right Contestants Voted Off American Idol?

American Idol brought the drama last night when not one but two contestants got the boot. Despite giving their best Elvis impersonations on Tuesday night, Katie Stevens and Andrew Garcia just didn't make the cut. Andrew's days were definitely up, but I was kinda surprised to see Katie go after her decent performance. Still, I didn't expect either to make it to the end of the competition, so it feels like we've trimmed some of the fat this week. What do you think — did America make the right call?

Don't forget to enter our giveaway for your chance to catch a live taping of the show!

Photo courtesy of Fox

Join The Conversation
xlightningboltx xlightningboltx 7 years
Indifferent over Katie, but I was quite sad to see Andrew go even though he hasn't been delivering. Tim should've left, too IMO.
Divinesally Divinesally 7 years
it should have been Tim and Andrew. not Katie.
zeze zeze 7 years
If they had sent them all home plus Ryan, I would have still voted "YES they are all overdue" Seriously, these are are worst singers ever on American Idol. I might be ok with Lee staying...might be.
care0531 care0531 7 years
It was time for Andrew to go but not Katie. Tim can't sing that well and needs to go. I also agree that Aaron needs to go. He has a good voice but is unoriginal. He sings everything just like the orginal.
bonggaboutique bonggaboutique 7 years
It's too bad about Katie. She was just starting to blossom and show America just what she was capable of. She actually took the advice the judges gave her and tried to incorporate it into her performance every week. Andrew should've been voted off LAST week. Heck, he should've been voted off a long time ago. If he was, Katie might still be there. If I could, I'd get rid of Aaron, Tim and Siobahn in one fell swoop to save us (mainly, me) the aggravation of having ot listen to them every week.
animatedpunk animatedpunk 7 years
It should have been Aaron and Andrew.... NOT Katie. She is talented and should have lasted a little longer. Aaron should have gone a while ago. Blah.
CupcakeGal10 CupcakeGal10 7 years
As charming as I find Tim, I thought his last performance was kind of boring - I would have voted him off sooner than Katie. I think she has incredible range, and might not be at "super star" point yet, but can certainly get there...her version of 'Let It Be' was amazing!!! I was sorry to see her go (although I'm sorry to see all of them go at this point - I think with the right songs, all of them have so much potential).
bonbon bonbon 7 years
Andrew was definitely a good choice to go but as for a second choice I think Aaron or Tim would of been better than Katie.
lilkimbo lilkimbo 7 years
No, I think it should have been Andrew and Aaron, not Andrew and Katie. Katie annoyed me a little at first, but I think she's gotten better with time. Aaron is annoying and not at all contemporary. Andrew has always been just kind of OK to me.
Jessica Sanchez Covers Beauty and the Beast Song
From Our Partners
Latest Entertainment
All the Latest From Ryan Reynolds