Skip Nav
Fall Movie Preview: 45 Movies You Need to Know About This Fall
Hot Damn, Netflix Has an AMAZING Selection of Horror Movies Right Now
Grey's Anatomy
4 Times Grey's Anatomy Has Used "The Tumor Plot"

Melissa Rosenberg Shares Her Vision For Breaking Dawn 2010-07-12 18:30:00

Exclusive: Twilight Screenwriter Melissa Rosenberg Shares Her Vision For Breaking Dawn and Just How Gory It Will Be!

Now that Eclipse has hit theaters and broken box office records, Twilight fans are already anxiously awaiting the next onscreen chapter in Bella and Edward's love story: Breaking Dawn. We talked exclusively to Melissa Rosenberg, the screenwriter behind all of the Twilight films, to find out what we can expect from the final two installments. She weighed in on whether or not Bella's childbirth scene will make it to the screen, shared her most surprising fan moment, and dished on her creative relationship with Stephenie Meyer.

Melissa will be speaking in LA at the Writer's Guild Foundation on Tuesday evening — tune into a livestream here. In the meantime, check out our all-new exclusive interview with her here now.

PopSugar: How did you feel about the decision to split Breaking Dawn into two movies?
Melissa Rosenberg: Relief, actually, because it was going to be quite a challenge to condense such a large book into one movie. That's always the challenge with all of these and, more so, Breaking Dawn. Having a little more room to breathe is nice . . . on the other hand, there's also the challenge of making sure there's enough to fill two movies.


PS: We've heard there are some scenes you want to avoid showing on screen in Breaking Dawn. For example, Bella giving birth. Can you tell us why?
MR: That was a misquote. The childbirth — all the scenes, I feel — should be on screen. I think perhaps what I was referring to was, would we actually see Edward's teeth through the placenta? I don't think so. I don't think we need to see that, and if someone needs to see that, I think they should take a look at that. [Laughs.] I believe it will be implied, but I don't think we'll see teeth in the placenta.

To read the rest of the interview about her craziest fan experience, her favorite scenes to write, and more, just


PS: What responsibility do you feel toward the fans? Are they on your mind during the writing process?
MR: The responsibility I feel to the fans? Well, there's one: making them happy, of course. I want people to enjoy the movie and not feel that I killed their favorite novel! But what I've realized is, you can't satisfy all the people. But the real weight that I feel is a very heavy responsibility, knowing that a lot of women and young girls are seeing this, and watching to make sure that what's portrayed in the film is that Bella's a strong female role model. That the messages they're getting are positive ones.

PS: What's the craziest or most surprising fan reaction you've experienced?
MR: You can't call it crazy, but crazy wonderful. I just came back from Paris. I was there [for a press junket] with some of the actors: Daniel Cudmore, Edi Gathegi, Michael Welch, and Alex Meraz. At the end, there was this closing ceremony and we were told there was a surprise for us, and they led us out on the stage . . . and the entire audience was sort of standing in this darkened theater, almost as if in prayer. It was very odd. And then after a moment, Lady Gaga's "Bad Romance" starts up, and they break into a dance they've been choreographing for three days. This wonderful, very unified dance, and it was amazing. We were stunned. A thousand pairs of hands all raised to the beat at the same time — it's a powerful experience . . . I wondered, could that have happened anywhere else but in France? Would American audiences have been too cool?

PS: How involved is Stephenie Meyer in the writing process and what is your relationship with her like?
MR: Stephenie is very involved. My relationship with her has only gotten better with every movie. When I met her and began to engage, I had no reason to be protective. I found her to be extremely collaborative and a tremendous resource. So I began to engage her more and that happened more on New Moon and even more in Eclipse . . . She weighs in on every draft of the outline, every draft of the script. She's on set. She's very involved.

PS: What is one of your favorite scenes from the books or films? Is there one you've especially enjoyed writing or look forward to writing?
MR: There are a number. I think seeing Bella as a vampire and her adjusting to her powers and embracing them, those are all really fun scenes to write. Particularly when you picture Kristen Stewart playing her, and the way she's embodied Bella as a sort of awkward, fidgety persona. When she turns into a vampire, all of that goes away.

Image Source: WireImage
redchick152 redchick152 7 years
hmmm, i dunno. the dialog has been pretty stale in the last 3 movies. i'm not expecting much else. plus, i don't see how Bella is a role model. she basically crumples up into nothing when her b/f leaves her and then wants to die to be with him forever. she is wimpy and dependent. granted, the 1st time i read these books, i love them. all this criticism has came out b/c i reread them. i'm just disappointed in general about how the movies have turned out. they could be SO MUCH BETTER!
Bri4everRob Bri4everRob 7 years
I agree mwolf she needs to stick to the book more this time. I couldn't believe when i saw Eclipse she didn't put the scene in it when Jacob gets cut for squeezing the knife. (which was my #2 fav scene in the book). Pleas stick to the book more this time and don't spare it for the children. These book are not children's books they are more like late teens-adults books. For crying out loud stick to the book more!
Mwolf Mwolf 7 years
When I got done reading Breaking Dawn I told my sister it was going t be tow movies because of they way it was written. We think that they are going to end the first movie when Bella goes into labor just to keep the people who haven't read the books in suspense to see if she and the baby live. Melissa please fallow the book more then the other three for god sake its the last one!!! We so want to see Bella get pissed at Jacob that's one of the best parts of the book, also I love the arm wrestling between Bella and Emmett, that was f*cking funny.
jaan_black jaan_black 7 years
Well, I think the first movie should end with her opening her eyes to see Edward but we shouldn't see her in her vampire form officially until the second as the first ends, we hear all the chaos and her thoughtas through the 3 day process, eyes open and then it goes black...this writer chick could've done way more with these movies and although I love them, I have to say they're all cheesier than they should be...the books had me going, the movies are OK...Eclipse was my fav (for the "action scenes") but the CGI looks like I did it lol...come on, they have a budget - use it...last two installments better be more pleasing to the eye and I want to see them f***...I have to rate them as a whole, 6.5 of 10 (so far)
Bella Swan's Engagement Ring From Twilight Sold in Auction
Scream Queens Joke About Taylor Lautner in Twilight
Twilight Jokes About the 2017 Solar Eclipse
From Our Partners
Latest Entertainment
All the Latest From Ryan Reynolds