Skip Nav
Try Not to Lose Your Mind Over the New Justice League Teasers
This Ed Sheeran and Bruno Mars Mashup Is Catchy as Hell
Grey's Anatomy
14 Dirty Grey's Anatomy Secrets, Straight From the Cast

NY Magazine Already Panning The Lovely Bones

Last week I brought you the news that Peter Jackson has written a screenplay adaptation of Alice Sebold's novel The Lovely Bones, a story told from the viewpoint of a 14-year-old girl who was raped and murdered. All Jackson neeeded was a studio to give him the money — and a lot of it. Variety claims the budget for Bones could run close to $90 million. Well, Jackson got someone to bite: DreamWorks.

So what will $90 million get you? New York Magazine has already reviewed Jackson's screenplay and the verdict is not great. Noting Jackson's successful fantasy-drama Heavenly Creatures, the New York Magazine writer figured The Lovely Bones would be equally promising. Not so, apparently.

Jackson doesn't get into Susie's head the way he did Pauline and Juliet's, and the incursion of the supernatural into everyday life feels showy rather than integral. The fantasy scenes in Heavenly Creatures were momentous, despite the shakiness of the special effects; though it's certain that the effects in The Lovely Bones will be brilliant, the scenes in Heaven, and Susie's interaction with Earth, don't have much magic on the page.

It certainly seems premature to dis on a movie that has a long way to go before it's a presentable film ready for critique, though I can't deny this article makes me slightly nervous for The Lovely Bones.


Around The Web
Join The Conversation
andaman andaman 9 years
Come to think of it, did peter write the lord of the ring himself? Perhaps he struggles with drama but not action?
andaman andaman 9 years
Well adaptation is hard work, If he has never done it before then it's not a surprise why it sucks, i wish he employs someone to visit the writing properly. He should get that guy who did the queen. That guy has a good theory in his head how visual should work.
chancleta chancleta 9 years
i started the book but it killed me to finish...however i'm interested to see the movie...i really wanna see what they do for heaven
blogsap blogsap 9 years
i feel like a person missing a sensitivity chip. i didn't love the book. and as far as a movie goes, all i can picture is ghost.
Megatron Megatron 9 years
I love that book, I have kinda mixed feelings about it being turned into a movie, though.
xxbrittney xxbrittney 9 years
i'm really looking forward to this movie and i'm keepin my fingers crossed that jackson gives it the justice it more than deserves
bugness bugness 9 years
Dakota Fanning? please no... she is so desperately not susie... -Bug
lickety-split lickety-split 9 years
to early to say either way, but i would expect a few re writes and changes along the way. i hear a dakota fanning voice over....
bugness bugness 9 years
I felt uneasy the moment I heard he was doing this film. Not that I dislike Peter Jackson, but feeling immensely close to this book, I was worried that it wouldn't be done justice in a movie. -Bug
brokenbracelet brokenbracelet 9 years
I loved that book so much! It really stayed with me for months and months afterwards
redsox26 redsox26 9 years
love that book. But I don't know if I can picture it being a movie.
Justinsbelle Justinsbelle 9 years
I would love to see a movie based on this novel! One of my favorites books of all time! f sexy never left, then why's everybody on my shit?
calibabi calibabi 9 years
this is a fantastic novel...i hope that a movie can do it justice.
Avatar Stays at No. 1 For Its Fifth Week at the Box Office
Exclusive Golden Globes Sneak Peek, Mark Talks New Baby, and Our Lovely Bones, Book of Eli Reviews!
Which Books Should Never Have Been Made Into Movies?
Photos of The Lovely Bones Premiere in LA 2009-12-08 11:00:34
Movie Preview For December 2009
Movie Preview: Peter Jackson's The Lovely Bones
Movie Preview: Peter Jackson's The Lovely Bones

POPSUGAR, the #1 independent media and technology company for women. Where more than 75 million women go for original, inspirational content that feeds their passions and interests.

From Our Partners
Latest Entertainment
All the Latest From Ryan Reynolds