Skip Nav
Stranger Things
Stranger Things Season 2: Everything We Know
Mindhunter: Your New Netflix Obsession Has (Terrifying) Roots in Reality
30 Friends Quotes You're Still Using Every Week

The Proposal: A Predictable Journey But Funny Along the Way

The story in The Proposal is relatively predictable at every turn, and the basic plotline is tired at best: two people who dislike each other are forced together and feelings blossom between them (to their surprise but not ours). Even just from the previews for this movie we know where the story is going from the very beginning, but before we reach the inevitable conclusion, The Proposal offers up some cute/funny/surprising things along the way.

The story follows ice-queen publishing executive Margaret Tate (Sandra Bullock) who is a demanding and sometimes cruel boss to her handsome, hard-working assistant, Andrew (Ryan Reynolds). She's certainly no Miranda Priestly, but she knows that Andrew is determined to succeed at the company so when Margaret learns that she'll be deported back to Canada unless she takes some drastic measures, she uses a promotion to bribe Andrew to marry her. Nobody's quite buying this relationship, however — including the folks at the immigration office who will send Andrew to prison (and Margaret to Canada) if they find out the relationship is a sham. So, the fake lovebirds travel to Andrew's hometown in Alaska for his Gammy's (Betty White) birthday to make sure anyone who might be questioned will be able to verify that the two really are in love and getting married. All sorts of awkward and weird hijinks ensue, during which the two learn a little bit about each other and themselves. Yeah,


The performances are what make this film good. Oscar Nuñez (Oscar from The Office) has a surprising role, woven delightfully into the narrative. He provides wonderful comedic relief during the more "dramatic" moments, and though he's used often, I almost wished we'd see even more of him. He was an inspired addition to an already fantastic and likable cast.

And, of course, Betty White steals a few scenes with her blithely sweet "but I'm just an old lady!" innocence — which of course masks a wicked sense of humor and mischievous streak. It's not a totally new device (the old woman who gets away with hilarious things because she's old and people underestimate her), but when Betty White does it she has such an endearing brightness you just want her to stay on screen forever. I wonder if I'll ever tire of Betty White's adorable bubbliness. I probably won't.

The first two-thirds of the movie, in which the snarky, thinly veiled disdain between our two protagonists (along with the fact that this is a professional relationship, so the usual rules of decorum that are ignored here make things even more awkward), are the most worthwhile. Or, worthwhile at all. These silly, jokey-joke moments are also the parts in which Reynolds and Bullock truly shine. They're both very comfortable with this material, and they excel at playing off one another as workplace acquaintances or even as buddies when their relationship begins to warm up. The sparky dynamic between them when they're trading barbs and trying to keep up appearances with gritted teeth is solidly entertaining. It's the real sexual chemistry that's lacking. As we come into the home stretch of the movie, all the tension, excitement, and fun of the previous hour or so comes to a screeching halt. Suddenly, words like "love" are being tossed about, as though they mean something in this situation. But while there's a clear fondness between the two characters by the end it's impossible to think of them as having deep feelings for one another.

All this doesn't negate the fact that there's some great stuff leading up to the ending. I just wish I'd had a fast-forward button for the last half-hour or so because it lags. And then we get to the credits, during which we're treated to some of the funniest parts of the whole movie. All in all, this will make the absolute best airplane movie: it's inoffensive, cute, and just entertaining enough to keep our attention.

Photos courtesy of Walt Disney Pictures

LOVErickii LOVErickii 8 years
i'm seeing it as a girls night out dinner/movie :)
reesiecup reesiecup 8 years
I agree with the review--it's a predictable plot but there were several hilarious and entertaining segments. Ryan Reynolds shirtless is also a bonus, making it at least worth renting!
crazy-fabulous crazy-fabulous 8 years
I would have loved to see Isla Fisher and Ryan Reynolds in something else...they were great together in Defenitely,Maybe Don't you think? I love Sandra Bullock though. I plan on seeing this becasue of her, hope it isn't a disapointment!
Grantz Grantz 8 years
That cute little dog's performance was great! If they gave wrangler awards, whoever worked on this film would have been nominated. What a smart little dog..
Grantz Grantz 8 years
Im just going to post the thoughts I shared in my movie group: ~ At the cinema, "The Proposal". Being the hopeless romantic that I am, I would have enjoyed this movie regardless of it's critical merrit. The theater manager and I were discussing why there wasnt any chemistry between Sandra Bullock and Ryan Reynolds. We agreed that the movie would have been much better if someone older like Steve Carrell or Keanu Reeves had been cast opposite Sandra Bullock. She is still a beautiful leading lady, but she is 44 years old now. And Ryan Reynolds was just too young to compliment Bullock's seasoned charm and elegance. We also decided Isla Fisher or Rachel McAddams would have worked much better opposite opposite Ryan Reynolds. Still, the film is not a bad romantic comedy. 2.5 stars out of 5
Entertainment Entertainment 8 years
Edie J — HA! That scene is actually pretty funny. I will PM you. :)
Linda-McP Linda-McP 8 years
Enjoyed the review, as always, Buzz. I'll add this to my Netflix list for sure.
Edie-J-Blige Edie-J-Blige 8 years
Buzz -- I'm def not going to see this in theaters but I'm dying to know how that cute puppy she's carrying in the last pic plays in. Care to spill? ;)
Kimpossible Kimpossible 8 years
I can't wait to see it!!!!
ilanac13 ilanac13 8 years
even though i'm sure that i know what will happen, i'm still excited to see this. you just have to love RR And SB
nancita nancita 8 years
Wow that sounds much better than it looks in the trailers. Too bad about the lack of chemistry though. That's so important, especially in a rom-com with a sort of outlandish plot, but it's very often lacking.
Rent Sandra Bullock's LA House
Pictures of Betty White's House
Blake Lively and Ryan Reynolds in NYC October 2017
Ryan Reynolds Refuses to Say Bossy Word to His Daughters
From Our Partners
Latest Entertainment
All the Latest From Ryan Reynolds