Skip Nav
Stranger Things
Stranger Things Season 2: Everything We Know
Grey's Anatomy
4 Times Grey's Anatomy Has Used "The Tumor Plot"
Game of Thrones
27 Game of Thrones Season 8 Theories to Read Until the Show Returns

The Results Are In: Recast My Two Dads

Every Wednesday on BuzzSugar, I post a Recast challenge, where I ask you to choose new actors for a classic TV show or movie. The reader who submits the best cast wins a BuzzSugar t-shirt!

One of my favorite recast lists for My Two Dads this week was mamaseacat's cheeky cast that combined Madonna's family and the Harry Potter movies. I also loved a lot of the ideas for casting the Judge, like msshellokitty's suggestion of Estelle Getty and gracieredrox's idea of Olympia Dukakis.

aembry396 is onto something with her suggestion of Jerry Stiller playing Ed Klawicki, though I have to say I really love sfmastiffmom's idea of Chi McBride in that role.

Overall, though, I would absolutely love to see nikkih's recast list actually play the parts in a new version of My Two Dads, so she wins this week's challenge! To see who nikkih picked, along with a new cast photo,

nikkih's cast:
Nicole Bradford — Kay Panabaker
Michael Taylor — Eric McCormack
Joey Harris — David Boreanaz
Judge Margaret W. Wilbur — Kelly Bishop
Ed Klawicki — Alec Baldwin
Cory — Josh Hutcherson

ChrissyBaby ChrissyBaby 9 years
Congrats nikkih!
lil-l lil-l 9 years
I love when you do "recast" Buzz! Soo much fun!
tiggerchick2 tiggerchick2 9 years
Congrats Nikki!! Good job :WOOHOO:
nikkih nikkih 9 years
Wow! Thanks, Buzz!! :woohoo:
bart-simpson bart-simpson 9 years
congrats! great picks! I also like the idea of Chi McBride, too! :)
mamaseacat mamaseacat 9 years
I'm always soooooo close. Thanks for the mention! I thought I was going to win for sure this time. :-) I'm gonna win me one of those BuzzSugar shirts one of these days.
msshellokitty msshellokitty 9 years
Congrats.i didn't win but it's cool to see my name up there.
beansandsyke beansandsyke 9 years
i dont know those two kids but the rest is awesome
Early 2000s Halloween Costumes
Ed Kemper Serial Killer in Real Life
Halloween Costume Ideas For Best Friends
Jane the Virgin Halloween Costumes
From Our Partners
Latest Entertainment
All the Latest From Ryan Reynolds