Skip Nav
Justice League: Try Not to Lose Your Mind Over This Insane Trailer
This Ed Sheeran and Bruno Mars Mashup Is Catchy as Hell
The Walking Dead
Everything We Know About the Season 7 Finale of The Walking Dead

The Results Are In: Recast Suddenly Susan

Every other Wednesday on BuzzSugar, I post a recast challenge, where I ask you to choose new actors for a classic TV show or movie. The reader who submits the best cast wins a BuzzSugar t-shirt!

Thanks to all of you who responded to my challenge to recast a '90s TV show that was a big hit for Brooke Shields: Suddenly Susan. There are quite a few characters on the show but I picked a batch to recast and you came through with flying colors.

The main character of Susan is a fun one to think about because she has to be someone who people want to root for even though she's full of flaws and quirks. Debra Messing comes to mind for this type of TV role and she'd probably make a great Susan — good thinking, ktpotat. I also think amadaarwen is on the right track with the suggestion of bombshell Heather Graham.

As for the supporting cast SugarKat's suggestion of Grant Show for Susan's love interest and boss Jack Richmond is brilliant. I also liked genesisrocks's idea of Charlie Sheen in that role. As for a wise-cracking funny lady to replace Kathy Griffin as Vicki, Miss Senorita is on the money with Janeane Garofalo. Finally, you will never get an argument from me when it comes to casting Freddy Rodriguez as Luis (another great idea from genesisrocks!).

It was hard to pick a winner but I had to go with a lead actress who I think would be totally lovable in this role paired with an adorable suggestion for her boss — congrats to Miss Shapes!

To see the cast that Miss Shapes thought up, along with a new cast photo,


Miss Shapes's cast:
Susan Keane — Lauren Graham
Jack Richmond — Jason Bateman
Vicki Groener — Amy Poehler
Luis Rivera — Rodrigo Santoro
Nana — Cloris Leachman

Around The Web
Join The Conversation
Miss-Shapes Miss-Shapes 8 years
OMG! I can’t believe you chose my cast. Thanks so much. I never tried recasting on Buzz before but I think I’m addicted now :)
Miss-Senorita Miss-Senorita 8 years
I'm happy with a shoutout. Congrats Miss Shapes!!!
SugarKat SugarKat 8 years
Woot! Woot! good job. Lauren Graham needs a new show! I ♥ her!
genesisrocks genesisrocks 8 years
Congrats! You deserve it!
Linda-McP Linda-McP 8 years
Congrats to all who are so creative in these recasts!
The Results Are In: Recast While You Were Sleeping
Recast Felicity Results
Recast Results for Speed
Recast Results for The Partridge Family
The Results Are In, Recast The Wonder Years
Recast Charles in Charge
The Results Are In: Recast Working Girl

POPSUGAR, the #1 independent media and technology company for women. Where more than 75 million women go for original, inspirational content that feeds their passions and interests.

From Our Partners
Latest Entertainment
All the Latest From Ryan Reynolds