Skip Nav
Stranger Things
Stranger Things Season 2: Everything We Know
9 Books That Became TV Shows This Year
Girls Trip
Exclusive: If You Thought Girls Trip Was Funny, Wait Till You See the Bloopers

Sex and the City 2 Poll: Is Big or Aidan Better for Carrie? 2010-04-26 09:30:00

Who Is Carrie's Best Sex and the City Match?

I hear you loud and clear! Even though Carrie and Big finally got hitched in the last Sex and the City movie, many of you have been quick to confess your undying devotion for Carrie's former flame Aidan, who just so happens to make an appearance in the upcoming sequel. Says reader CdnPhotog, "I always wanted Big and Carrie together. But now ... after seeing that trailer, Aidan and Carrie don't seem like such a bad idea."

I don't want to go picking favorites between the two men, but I was always a big supporter of Aidan on the TV series — and I hated when they split. Even though the preview hints that the two will have a reconciliation (and possibly even an affair!) in part two, I doubt Aidan can come between Carrie and Big. Which guy has your support?

SaraJeanQueen SaraJeanQueen 7 years
I never thought Carrie and Big had ANY chemistry whatsoever. What is romantic about them, other than the looks SHE gives him, and that he built her a closet?? He couldn't even get out of the car to get married to her!!! WTF!!! Aidan would never, never have done this. On the show, I felt that Carrie and Aidan had the most beautiful relationship ever portrayed on television. He was such a good listener. When she wanted space so he read on his leather chair and watched her through the curtain... when he built that love seat and they made out on it.. when he supported her with the quitting of smoking.. even their last night together, cuddling on the hardwood floors he built for their new apartment. SATC made a big, Big mistake with this one.
jadenirvana jadenirvana 7 years
Aidan was the safe guy you rebound with. Big is the love of Carrie's life. Those two together personify glamorous New York!
jlr32phl jlr32phl 7 years
i agree with animatedpunk. as much as i LOVE aiden, my ultimate opinion is that carrie doesn't deserve him. she blew it twice with him and if they put them together again in the movie it will make me like his character less for giving her a third chance!
Tightropemarvel Tightropemarvel 7 years
Please don't let Aiden come in between Carrie and Big!! Aiden's a good guy but Carrie and Big are Meant To Be.
pargie pargie 7 years
kismekate I wish you would have kept that to yourself, now you're ruining it for the rest of us. I love Aidan and yup, I think he's better off without Carrie. I agree that Big is more suited for Carrie, even though I'd never in a million years go out with him. P.S. Love "Aidan" on U.S. of Tara...he has that nice guy/rugged act down.
bingbingboom bingbingboom 7 years
I agree with animedpunk, Aidan is too good and stable for Carrie. She doesn't deserve him.
Dana18 Dana18 7 years
you must always go with your heart ! Carrie loves Big and that is why she could not be faithful to Aidan.
reesiecup reesiecup 7 years
Looks like most of us are split. I think both men compliment her in different ways. Big is the dreamy, rich, witty, reformed player but Aidan is the down-to-earth, artistic, steady, sensitive one. Doesn't he have a kid now? That could complicate things for Carrie. I remembered during the show, I always thought Carrie should be with Big in the end. But definitely Aidan seemed like the perfect guy, until she broke his trust.
Lampaaa Lampaaa 7 years
Blah Blah Blah, yeah deffs Carrie will probably always end up with Big, But Aidan was alllllwaaayss better for her! GO AIDAN! <3
reeniehoo reeniehoo 7 years
Carrie is damaged (no judging) just like Big. She can have him. Carrie definitely did Aidan a favor by not staying with him. He's too perfect. :) Clearly, everyone ought to know where my allegiance lie. haha
bohokitty bohokitty 7 years
Aidan bugs me too...I never really thought about why and I think it is 'cause he's just really good and really nice. Big has more of an edge to him (if that makes any sense). Carrie and Big just have better chemistry imo.
indiaheart indiaheart 7 years
Carrie and Adian were not well suited for each other...God, remember the episodes in the "country"...I'd take an Adian for myself but Carrie is Mr. Big all the way!
redchick152 redchick152 7 years
definitely Big. it's always been Big. Carrie and Aidan just didn't have the crazy, passionate, irrational chemistry that she and Big have together.
kismekate kismekate 7 years
I chose Aidan. I loved him on the show. However, I did get a chance to meet him in real life and he was an ASS HOLE. Quite a disappointing moment.
tlsgirl tlsgirl 7 years
Aidan bores the crap out of me. I never liked them when they were together, but I always like Carrie and Big, even when things weren't good between them. They're just meant to be together. Aidan just struck me as the high school sweetheart type, which makes me yawn.
anabj anabj 7 years
animatedpunk, that´s my husband´s opinion
postmodernsleaze postmodernsleaze 7 years
I always hear girls talk about how sweet and nice Aidan was so he should be with Carrie. However, I have to disagree. While Aidan is adorable and sweet, him and Carrie just did not mesh. Carrie's more cosmopolitan and Aidan's a little bit too country. He's sweet and loyal and likes to stay in. Carrie likes to go out and be a city girl. Big and Carrie are a much better match just based on personality. Aidan is the boyfriend we'd all love to have, but him and Carrie were just not right for eachother.
animatedpunk animatedpunk 7 years
I chose Big..... because Aidan is TOO GOOD for Carrie!! He deserves better. Carrie and Big deserve each other and work well together.
lwimbush lwimbush 7 years
it's funny because i think aidan was such a better boyfriend, so devoted, etc. he definitely seems like the better choice, right? but that's not what love is. love is passionate and irrational and i think it makes sense for the show, whether or not aidan was the "right choice", that she ended up with BIg.
15 Halloween Movies That Aren't Scary
'90s Pop Culture Halloween Costumes
What Has Edgar Ramirez Been In?
Halloween Costume Ideas For Couples
From Our Partners
Latest Entertainment
All the Latest From Ryan Reynolds