Skip Nav
The Bachelor
If You're Rooting For Tayisha Adams to Be Colton's Pick on The Bachelor, This Is For You
The Bachelor
Hannah B. and Caelynn Didn't Get Along Way Before The Bachelor — Here's Why
The Bachelor
7 Things to Know About The Bachelor's Troublemaker, Demi Burnett
Why The Bachelor Season 23 Shouldn't Focus on Age
The Bachelor
The Bachelor's Ridiculous Cougar Comments Are Laughable, but the Ageism Flows Both Ways
The Bachelor
Excuse Us, but We're So Impressed by This Bachelor Contestant's Makeup Skills

Should Older Books Be Updated For a Modern Audience?

I spent a good portion of Thursday afternoon being horrified by the fact that, in the newly updated versions of the Sweet Valley High books, the gorgeous Wakefield twins' oft-referenced clothing size has been reduced from a "perfect" six to a "perfect" four — a fact the publisher proudly trumpeted in a press release. It's as though Random House sat down with the '80s editions and thought, "huh, these unrealistic expectations just aren't quite unrealistic enough!"

The Wakefield waistline isn't the only thing they've changed: Instead of a red Fiat, the girls now drive a red Jeep Wrangler (I thought they said 2008, not 1998!), and brainy Elizabeth edits her school's website and blogs rather than working for those boring dead tree things we used to call "newspapers."

This reminded me of an interview with Judy Blume I heard last Fall, where she talked about deleting some of the menstruation "equipment" from updated editions of Are You There God? It's Me, Margaret (and taking a mimeograph machine out of Fudge). She said she didn't want to confuse kids and make them ask their parents to explain how things were back in the day.

Do you think it's necessary to update references in older books so they make sense to a younger crowd? Or is the tinkering just unnecessary?


From Our Partners
Thrillers and Mystery Books to Read in Winter 2019
Mindy Kaling's Favorite Board Books For Babies
Sad YA Books
Best New Books January 2019
Great Gatsby-Themed Wedding
Books by First-Time Authors 2019
Best 2019 Winter Books For Women
Books by Women Coming Out in 2019
Books Being Made Into Movies 2019
You Caroline Kepnes Book Spoilers
Book Tattoo Ideas
Book Quote Tattoos
From Our Partners
Latest Entertainment
All the Latest From Ryan Reynolds