Skip Nav
Stranger Things
Stranger Things Season 2: Everything We Know
7 Horror Movie and TV Locations You Can Visit in Real Life
These 46 New Titles Coming to Netflix in November Will Help You Survive Thanksgiving

Which American Idol Contestant Is Going Home?

The top 12 American Idol contestants treated us to songs from the Beatles songbook on Tuesday. Tonight, one of them is going home. Which singer will be the unlucky first to be booted from the finals?

Photo courtesy of Fox

TheAsianDiva TheAsianDiva 9 years
Michael Johns
orisugar orisugar 9 years
UGH I hate KLC!!! I hated the way she said "thanks simon, love you" it sickened me.
x_juicyfruit x_juicyfruit 9 years
Kristy Lee Cook. That was the worst performance I've ever seen in my life. What a butchering of a great song.
Underdog Underdog 9 years
Now I can Disguise the Bottom 3 Ramiele because her song was Boring, David Hernandez because he overdid his Song, but Kristy Lee is Going Home Because that's was not Country it was Bluegrass face It Onbody like her Performance not even Paula So I think she asking to go Home.
lizzylu49 lizzylu49 9 years
I think Kristy is too obvious. When people bomb, their fans will all vote like crazy. It could be Syesha and MAYBE Ramiele. Both forgettable.
kelsey6 kelsey6 9 years
I really think Kristy Lee will go home, but I wish David Cook would get voted off! His performance was okay, but he sounds like every other pop-rock male performer today, and if he won I'm sure everyone would forget about him right away.
orisugar orisugar 9 years
Kristy Lee (anyone noticed how she makes these creepy big eyes when she sings?) then David Hernandez (that guy annoys me so much, plus his rendition of she was just 17 was horrendous) then Sayesha (she totally butchered that poor song) then Amanda (i can't take her screeching) then Jason Castro (his voice just isnt strong enough) then Chakeezie (he's a bit corney and i don't see anything original in him) My favorites: David Archeletta (i know he messed up last night, but based on his earlier performances he is incredible- fyi i have this insuppressible urge to pinch him) Michael John (i think he's an amazing singer...ok i wouldnt kick him out of bed either, but seriously the man is a great performer and i can see him selling alot of records with that body...i mean voice..ha) Carley (great voice and performer) David Cook (i like his singing style and i think i'd buy his album if he made one)
thelorax thelorax 9 years
Kristy Lee needs to be banished for SLAUGHTERING the timelessly endearing "8 Days A Week" - one of my favorites. I'm pretty sure my mouth was hanging agape while watching the horror unfold - did she really think that sounded good??? If not Kristy Lee, then David Hernandez. He's not bad, but he isn't amazing. Syesha was similarly underwhelming last night. David Cook, on the other hand, was absolutely incredible - he is not only a performer, he is an ARTIST! I think I have a new favorite.
Leanne1078 Leanne1078 9 years
Kristy's song was not only bad, but she didn't look confident--it looked like she was faking confidence. I don't understand why the tempo of that song was so fast, it made it like twice as bad as it would have been if it was a little slower. It was embarrassing.
xhn xhn 9 years
Haha, I love how David Archuleta has 0 votes. He was definitely in the bottom half of the group last night, but I love him though!
Phasekitty Phasekitty 9 years
I love Kristy, but last night was unbearable. That being said, she is DARN cute and has made it this far...considering the so-called "scandal," and last night's over the top and forgettable performance, there's a chance America could surprise you and David Hernandez could get the boot. Based on last night's performances, I'd have to say the bottom three would be David Hernandez, Kristy Lee, and Syesha.
SweetPeasMom SweetPeasMom 9 years
Kristy or Sayesha.
Daisie Daisie 9 years
Kristy should go home. What she did to that song was atrocious. The singing wouldn't have been *that* bad if the music was more Faith Hill than honky tonk. That said, American Idol rigs things a bit so I'm not surprised someone didn't tell her " may want to rethink that." They give praise, they must give criticism. Though she may have wanted to stay with that..who knows.
marcella marcella 9 years
for the first time ever i caught a bit of this shit show. i was flipping channels and heard some douchebag with dreadlocks screeching with a guitar. i don't know what his name is, but he was god awful. i thought my ears were going to bleed. never channel surf and throw fox into the mix!
aoitenshi aoitenshi 9 years
Kristy's performance was really bad. I couldn't believe my ears when I heard her take on the song. :/
stina829 stina829 9 years
I'd be shocked if anyone other than Kristy went home.
eggmaker eggmaker 9 years
how could 4 people vote for Chikezie after last night's performance??? It was by far the best one of the night. He did so great.
lilkimbo lilkimbo 9 years
I agree, ricki. I liked Chikeze at first, then didn't like him for a while, but after last night I definitely like him again! And I still like Ramiele, but you're right, had she been after a lot of the contestants, she would have seemed a little bit better.
jflutterjess jflutterjess 9 years
Carly rocks! I think Brooke is really talented!
rickimc rickimc 9 years
Chikezie totally rocked last night! I loved the engergy he had and that he did something different. I think Ramiele seems worse because she did such a boring song with a boring performance right after him.
New American Idol Judges 2018
Jessica Sanchez Covers Beauty and the Beast Song
From Our Partners
Latest Entertainment
All the Latest From Ryan Reynolds