Ashley Tisdale [1] and Taran Killam sharing a past might sound pretty random, but it's not any less true. On Wednesday's episode of The Late Late Show With James Corden [2], the 34-year-old High School Musical [3] actress and 37-year-old comedian sat down and reminisced about their early careers, revealing they met over a decade ago on a trip to Magic Mountain.

"I obviously used to watch him all the time on SNL, and I would say to my husband, 'I think I know him.' I felt like I went to Six Flags with him," Tisdale said. "And we have. It really did happen." Killam then explained how their mutual friend — and his costar in Disney Channel's 2004 film Stuck in the Suburbs — Brenda Song played a part in connecting them 16 years ago. Above, watch their major déjà vu moment before learning how Ashley also used her Disney connections to flex on her ex-boyfriends!