It's been over 10 years since Brandi Carlile released the folk-rock single "The Story," but the song is still drawing shivers down our spine [1] — especially when Kelly Clarkson [2] is covering it! On Nov. 19, The Kelly Clarkson Show [3] host opened the episode by switching out her usual jaunty "Kellyoke" cover [4] for the emotional ballad, and the singer's powerful vocals fit the melody perfectly. From the darkened stage to Clarkson's glam dress, it feels like we're watching a concert performance rather than a daytime show! And we would not be mad if Clarkson decided to release her version as a track, along with the rest of her covers [5] of course. Watch the full video of the intimate performance above.