The first official look at Netflix's You [1] season two is here, and it's even creepier than we imagined. The trailer is filled with intriguing glimpses of what's to come [2], including the return of Candace [3] and the introduction of Joe's new love [4], but one of the best parts has to be the featured song. As Joe narrates his move to LA, a cover of Radiohead's "Creep" plays in the background.

So, just who is singing the haunting melody? It's early-2000s icon Michelle Branch! Shortly after the trailer was released, the "All You Wanted" singer tweeted, "Who is that I hear? 🙃 Joe is such a creep [5]." Listen to her full cover ahead before You season two drops on Netflix on Dec. 26.