Somewhere around their tween years, Mary-Kate and Ashley Olsen [1] decided to ditch the matching twin thing [2] and embrace individual style. But that doesn't mean their specific tastes don't overlap from time to time, causing them to step out wearing the same item — they do design together, after all. It happened again on Wednesday, when Ashley was spotted in Mary Jane shoes from The Row. "Where have we seen these before?" we thought, struggling to remember. Oh yeah — Mary-Kate wore the exact same pair [3] just the other night.

It's not like we can blame them, though. These single-strap flats are just as cozy as they are elevated and pair well with a variety of looks from jeans to formalwear. Take a look at how each sister styled this must-have shoe ahead.

Ashley Olsen Was Spotted Out in a Mary Jane Flat From The Row

She Paired the Shoe With Navy Pants, a Dark Coat, and a Scarf

Mary-Kate Recently Wore the Same Shoe to a Sotheby's Celebration

The Shoe

The Row Ava Mary Jane Flats [4] ($995)