comscore-tag
Do You Agree With the Project Runway Judges' Decision Last Night?
Do You Agree With the Project Runway Judges' Decision Last Night?

For the first time in this season of Project Runway, I completely disagree with the judges' decision. Sorry, Nina! The challenge was to create a day-to-night look for Brooke Shields's character on Lipstick Jungle — really cool. Sophisticated, bohemian, and sharp was what I envisioned. Seeing the team dynamics is always entertaining, but the results were polarizing. After the models walked, I knew who the bottom and top looks were. Spoiler on its way . . . I did not expect Kelli to get sent home for an overly-sexy look while Blayne stayed for his tousled styling and gray Bermuda shorts; after Heidi said it looked like someone who had gotten dressed in the dark without a mirror, I thought the decision was made. So yeah, I totally thought Blayne should have gotten the ax. Maybe I'm alone here, you tell me?

Source

Comments
estella241
estella241
I really don't understand why Jerrell didn't win. Keith's outfit was fine, but they didn't provide any information of why Keith's trumped Jerrell's. I agreed with sending Kelli home; the outfit looked like it was made out of polyester and from Walmart. Blayne's outfit was not appropriate for the character, but I thought it was pretty cute, minus the skin-tight shorts.
kathili
kathili
Kelli's taste seemed to border on trashy, plus Blayne took responsibility for his poorly received design. I didn't find his design that appalling. I didn't like the skirt on Keith's outfit much; it looked kind of clownish....I wish the other one had won.
hollitosway
hollitosway
The judges must know something we don't know to keep Blayne. I know that the pencil skirt is pretty easy to make compared to a shirt and nice-fitting pants.
mcollazo
mcollazo
Bustier is already vampy and then just to add animal print to it...and what is that crap on the bottom of the skirt. The outfit looked like it came out of Charolette Russe. Blayne on the other hand at least had good constuction even though his piece was not the idea of the challenge.
itsme3683
itsme3683
I loved Jerrel's too, the one that won seemed super easter-sunday to me. I totally agree with their decision, though. Blayne's might have been way too casual, but it at least looked well made, and those shorts fit like a glove. Kelli's didn't fit well and didn't look well made at all, and the fabrics she chose looked so cheap. I mean, I'd WAY sooner show up in Bermuda shorts to work and make up an excuse about the kids than show up looking ultra tarty in a cheap belly-baring bustier that deflates me boobs.
Rabbit88
Rabbit88
and i thought that jarell should have won as well. so i guess i disagree for ANOTHER week.
Rabbit88
Rabbit88
except from this week... i've disagreed with every single judging to this point!!! i haven't liked anything of kelli's anyway so i wasn't that disappointed to see her go. while i think blayne does have a point of view (despite him being extremely annoying) Her outfit was tacky and tasteless.
bronzebeauty719
bronzebeauty719
Jerrel should have won!! his outfit was definitely the best...the winner's outfit had a cool concept but in my opinion looked somewhat like a skirt from saks with a top from arden b...
lilprisci
lilprisci
It IS a reality show i.e. they keep those with "stronger" (read: annoying) personalities.
melody20
melody20
Must agree. I could NEVER go to work dressed like that. It´s a great look to go out, but my idea of day to night is a look you wear to work on friday and that allows you to go straight to a night out. The bermuda is hideous, but at least is something you can actually use.
lovehenry
lovehenry
What about Daniel? He was a total good for nothing and basically admitted that he was half-assing the job. He needs to go.
starbright14
starbright14
I think Kelli lost because her outfit looked so CHEAP... like something you'd buy at Wet Seal - not classy at all.
shopgirl123
shopgirl123
the second outfit is disgusting! first is a little overdone but i still prefer it!
everthewild
everthewild
Last night made me rather angry. First, I still think Jerell's was the best. I watch Lipstick Jungle, and that outfit was much more fitting with the character. Also, Kelli's outfit was not glamorous, but honestly, I thought Daniel should have gone home long ago. Freaking cocktail dresses! ALL THE TIME!!! Blayne is weird, but there is many a runway I've looked at with the same "what?" face. Also, Kelli's creation was beautiful when they had the supermarket challenge. It showed she was inventive, thoughtful, and creative. I just hate how one bad turn was her end, whereas Daniel's creations are always mediocre at best. He can't even sew in a straight line (the skirt!)!
outofhere
outofhere
I have been disappointment with ProjectRunway this season. I have disagreed with several of the judges choices and the designers are borrrrrrrrring. Worst season yet so far, in my opinion.
bussbuss
bussbuss
i had the HUGE pleasure of seeing both in person at the projectrunway.com offices today and even though i hated kelli's outfit last night, it was much better in person. it was actually really well constructed (shocker!) and didn't look so cheap or tackariffic. plus, it is something Wendy Healy would wear...she just needed to lengthen the bustier. Blayne's was well made, but it wall about daytime. I think BS thought she'd take a chance on Blayne, hoping he would make it work for the office and nighttime, but since he used all day fabrics, it looked very Old Navy. Wendy Healy is not Old Navy. Check out all of the designs he's done altogether: http://www.bussbuss.com/blog.php I think what we're dealing with HERE is a taste level issue! Ditto Stella and Kelli...
thrifty-trendy
thrifty-trendy
I was really surprised Jerrel didn't win. He deserved it.
leeluvfashion
leeluvfashion
Kelli had to go home, the outfit looked extremely cheap/tacky. Unless you want to get stopped on a street corner, this outfit is a no for any person, let alone wear it on a fashionable tv show! Blayne didn't do well either however the outfit was far too casual, not tacky. He still gets on my nerves...
Melo-D
Melo-D
Jerrel should have won. Hands down. That outfit was great. It wasn't a borderline cocktail dress. What makes it even worse is Brooke was ecstatic when the model came down the runway. I don't know how that's doesn't scream winner but whatever. Kelli was the right choice to go home. Execution and design are key. She tried to throw it on Daniel when he handled the skirt. He made it work despite screwing up the rouching. The top was horrendous! She made that. She stuck that craptastic fabric on the bust. She made that thing craptastically short and not so well made. Oy. I'd rather be in Blayne's outfit than Kelli's.
bvfashion
bvfashion
I don't love the bermuda shorts outfit, but that whole bustier mess is much worse. That being said, even though it was Kelli's design, I don't think she should have been sent home. Daniel has nothing right, and he definitely does not have "impeccable taste" as he claims. And his execution is consistently flawed.
brista
brista
The Bermuda shorts did not win. The designer (along with the bustier leopard outfit's designer) were up for elimination. I keep thinking I like the Bermuda shorts outfit but then I look at it and think, "Nah." I think I just really love the color combo or something.
Mintie
Mintie
I don't watch PR... but are you saying the bermuda shorts won? BS' [no pun intended] character would NEVER wear bermuda shorts... not even to the park to not watch her kids while she's on her cell phone.
Glittersniffer
Glittersniffer
...no picture of Katto/Joe's design? BOO!
cnyc1a
cnyc1a
Honestly if I was a serious aspiring designer I would never want to be on project runway. I honestly think reality TV sets you up for failure is you aren't already established
Glittersniffer
Glittersniffer
I just have to say that Jerrell was ROBBED. That outfit was SEX. As far as whether it should've been Kelli or Blayne, can't say I care much for either of them. Kelli's outfit was feh, and Blayne is trying far too hard to be good TV. So 6 of one, half dozen of the other!
Join The Conversation