Skip Nav
Street Style
Ciao, Bella! The Best Street Style From Milan Fashion Week
Michelle Obama
Michelle Obama's Most Magnificent Gowns
Selena Gomez
No Star Has Ever Pulled a Style Switch-Up Like Selena Gomez

Who Wore It Better? Sequined Balenciaga Babydoll Dress

Remember that gorgeous sequined Balenciaga babydoll dress Sienna Miller wore to the premiere of Factory Girl? Well, during my usual morning visit to PopSugar today, I caught Katie Holmes wearing the same dress seven months later! This is a tough call because both ladies are wearing black opaque tights and patent pumps — almost identical. I approve of both. Who gets your vote?

Source, Flynet

Join The Conversation
Leighanna Leighanna 9 years
I don't like the dress either but Sienna looks better in it.
Lys-Villota Lys-Villota 9 years
I think it suits best a pregnant woman or a very thin silouhette. so sienna for me even if I don;t find it extraordinary
Kel Kel 9 years
Just looks better on Sienna
pollypo pollypo 9 years
Katie's hair looks awful and this dress does nothing for her. Someone needs to tell her that her legs are not made for short dresses.
AMP AMP 9 years
They both look adorable, but I think Sienna wore it at a more appropriate time/venue/event.
Katikins Katikins 9 years
YUCK! Has anyone else noticed what this dress does to the bust area! It looks smashed and uncomfortable on both ladies. Yikes. In theory I like the dress, but something has to be done about the bustline!
britt2121 britt2121 9 years
Sienna. It's hard to beat her.
vouninou vouninou 9 years
I don't like so much the dress it self ... I feel like the "waist line" isn't on a right place ... too high for a regular waist line ... too low for an empire style
Asia84 Asia84 9 years
it's more of sienna's look than it is katie's.
paradisee paradisee 9 years
Umh i think they look exactly the same
lala788 lala788 9 years
they both look OK to me.
4jaylo2004 4jaylo2004 9 years
Sienna looks really dresse3d up, going to a formal event. Katie looks like she is going on "play date" with her child andother mommys.
OliveBlack OliveBlack 9 years
Sienna, it flatters her more.
melody20 melody20 9 years
This dress make both of them look fat and breastless... :-S It might be used with Britney´s brown boots for the worse look of the year!
PrincessTracy PrincessTracy 9 years
Not a Sienna fan, but she looks better in it.
veronicaraye veronicaraye 9 years
Sienna cause she looks better & I don't like Kate Holmes.
stpattygirl stpattygirl 9 years
Sienna looks better. Katie looks dumpy in it, and she's not dumpy looking at all in most of her clothes.
bhustle bhustle 9 years
Sienna rocked this dress better than Katie who looks a bit swollen.
Linny Linny 9 years
they both look like they are wearing backpacks and you can see the straps
sugarsister sugarsister 9 years
this dress is wrong no matter who's in it
DCStar DCStar 9 years
While I LOVE the color combination of ivory & black, I hate this dress, because it makes one look like they're wearing a backpack!! Ridiculous. Also, it contorts the boobs.
Scarlet39 Scarlet39 9 years
It may be Balenciaga, but it is horrid.
girliceclimber girliceclimber 9 years
Sienna has a smaller chest which is what these babydoll, high waistline dresses look best on, IMO (although I'm not totally wild about the dress).
SarahwithanH SarahwithanH 9 years
I love that dress! They both look fantastic!
ccsugar ccsugar 9 years
Sienna... Not a fan of hers AT ALL but she wears it much better than Katie.
The Unexpected Way to Pull Off Ladylike Style Like Sienna Miller
Katie Holmes Snaps a Selfie With Suri Cruise at the Hair Salon
Sienna Miller Makeup and Hair at the 2017 Golden Globes
Katie Holmes Is Going Back to School
From Our Partners
Latest Fashion
All the Latest From Ryan Reynolds