No matter how organized and careful you are, it may seem impossible to get through a whole season without at least one item growing feet and walking away. Whether it's a solitary glove, a hat strategically stashed who-knows-where, or a scarf nonchalantly shed once and never recovered, nobody wants to be left frustrated on a blustery day. With that in mind, we combed through Old Navy's inventory [1] to find the best budget-friendly scarves, hats, and gloves that'll keep you warm this fall.
We rounded up the best of the best. You can find a pair of convertible mittens that can either cover your fingers or allow them to breathe, a snug poncho ideal for draping over your computer desk when you need warmth, and a Fair Isle-patterned scarf that evokes the cozy charm of your favorite fall sweater [2], and much more. One thing's for sure: you have plenty of options when it comes to complementing your fall wardrobe [3]. Keep scrolling to shop our eight favorite hats, gloves, and scarves from Old Navy for fall 2023, starting at $10.
Best Mittens
Old Navy Convertible Sherpa-Trim Mittens [5] ($10, originally $17)
These mittens are convertible, allowing you to either fully cover your hands or expose your fingers when it's too warm. Select from two available colors: brown and beige.
Best Scarf
Old Navy Brushed Scarf [6] ($20)
This scarf comes in several different colorways and features fun fringe edges. It's highly rated, too, with a near-perfect five-star rating. "This thing is amazing," wrote a pleased reviewer. "Bought it on a whim and SO GLAD I did. Super soft and warm. Also neutral enough that I can pair it with ANYTHING."
Best Beanie
Old Navy Gender Neutral Wide Cuff Beanie Hat [7] ($10, originally $13)
Chances are you'll want this beanie in more than one color. It comes in both neutrals and bolder pops of color, and shoppers say it's soft and stretchy.
Best Rib-Knit Scarf
Old Navy Rib-Knit Scarf [8] ($20)
Fresh from the brand's new arrivals section, this rib-knit scarf features a cozy, ribbed-knit design. We love how many bright colors it comes in, including the green one pictured here, as well as royal blue and hot pink, among others.
Best Cable-Knit Hat
Old Navy Wide Cuff Beanie Hat [9] ($10, originally $15)
Prefer your beanie to have a bit more texture? Take a look at this cable-knit-patterned style, complete with a wide brim with rib-knit detailing.
Best Flannel Scarf
Plaid Flannel Scarf [10] ($20)
This brushed flannel scarf has over 1,500 five-star ratings from shoppers. It comes in several flannel colorways, including perfect-for-fall options like this brown plaid design and a predominantly monochrome pink style with pops of red.
Best Poncho
Old Navy Flannel Poncho [11] ($30)
An Old Navy shopper brilliantly labeled this poncho "THE gift for the holiday season," writing: "Who doesn't freeze in the office or want to cuddle up during a good streaming binge?? This soft, cozy shawl is the answer." It comes in multiple colorways and boasts a stylish hi-low hem.
Best Fair Isle Scarf
Old Navy Fair Isle Scarf [12] ($20)
Whether you pair this scarf with your favorite Fair Isle sweater or wear it as a standalone accessory, we're confident you'll discover countless ways to style it. The texture is reminiscent of a cozy blanket, a testament to how frequently you'll want to wrap yourself up in its warmth.