The highly-anticipated season seven reunion of "Love Island USA" [1] brought a slew of drama. From the season's winners Amaya Espinal [2] and Bryan Arenales addressing cheating rumors to the validity of Jeremiah Brown and Austin Shepard's brotherhood being questioned, cringe was an overarching theme of the night. But all drama aside, the islanders were challenged to sport their sartorial best to discuss the season's most viral moments — a trend that has been set with Andy Cohen's tenure as the host for reunions such as "The Real Housewives" franchise. The legendary TV personality joined the season-seven stars, along with the show's impeccably-dressed host Ariana Madix [3] for a night full of tea, and the looks were definitely referential.
Madix, who's cemented herself as the fashion icon of the "Love Island USA" world, showed up in a blue-and-purple sequined mermaid-esque gown from Jean Pierre Khoury Couture's spring/summer 2025 collection that featured a plunging neckline, a subtle cutout right below the bust, and embellished 3D flowers. Contestants like Huda Mustafa [4] and Andreina Santos also looked to high-end designers for their ensembles, wearing a velvet floral dress from Roberto Cavalli's fall/winter 2006 collection and an Hervé Léger bandage dress [5], respectively. Meanwhile, couples Nic Vansteenberghe and Olandria Carthen and Chelley Bissainthe and Ace Greene wore custom gold and green looks — the ladies in gowns from Julian Mendez Couture [6] and Jagne [7] specifically.
Ahead, check out the best outfits from the "Love Island USA" season seven reunion, and shop available and similar pieces to grab for your next formal event.
Bryan Arenales and Amaya Espinal at the "Love Island USA" Reunion
The season's winning couple stepped out in looks that were worthy of the winner title: Espinal's blush pink minidress adorned with organza bows at the chest and hip was paired with neutral heels; and Arenales's purple plaid overshirt, white button-down, black tie, and black slacks looked modern.
Get the Look: Tularosa Camille Mini Dress [8] ($171, originally $228). Amanda Uprichard x Revolve Anja Mini Dress [9] ($204, originally $255). Stuart Weitzman Dancer 95 Pump [10] ($198). Banana Republic Slim-Fit Oxford Shirt [11] ($35, originally $70). Boss Solid Silk Tie [12] ($98). Banana Republic Slim-Straight Lived-In Chino [13] ($43, originally $85).
Ace Greene and Chelley Bissainthe at the "Love Island USA" Reunion
As one of the final four couples, Bissainthe and Greene pulled out all the stops with their looks. The Florida-bred beauty was in a custom gold fringe dress by Jagne, while Greene looked dapper in a dark-green three-piece suit and black loafers.
Get the Look: Sofia Fringe High Slit Midi Dress [14] ($100). Cult Gaia Mara Dress [15] ($898).
Ariana Madix at the "Love Island USA" Reunion
Ariana Madix was definitely best dressed for the "Love Island USA" season seven reunion, wearing a cutout sequin gown from Jean Pierre Khoury.
Get The Look: Bronx and Banco Dahlia Gown [16] ($880). Dress The Population Fernanda Sequin Strapless Gown [17] ($368).
Olandria Carthen and Nic Vansteenberghe at the "Love Island USA" Reunion
The show's star couple, affectionately known as "Nicolandria," stepped out in coordinating gold ensembles — Carthen in a custom bedazzled gown by Julian Mendez Couture and Vansteenberghe in a custom suit by Gray.
Get the Look: Michael Costello x Revolve Coletta Gown [18] ($279). Lovers and Friends Charlotte Maxi Dress [19] ($183, originally $228).
Belle-A Walker at the "Love Island USA" Reunion
Though she left the season early on, Belle-A came back turning heads in a green cutout dress by Dodona that featured a slew of sultry details: a deep-V neckline, extreme side cutouts, a high slit at the left leg, and a floor-length train.
Get the Look: Dodona Avdiu Stasia Dress [20] ($930). Superdown Adele Halter Maxi [21] ($88)
Andreina Santos at the "Love Island USA" Reunion
Santos's reunion look was right on trend with the bandage dress renaissance — she sported the Remi Gown from Hérve Léger. Her exact piece is sold out, but you can shop other picks that achieve a similar vibe below.
Get The Look: Nookie Boulevard Maxi Dress [22] ($289). Khy x Dilara Findikoglu Fitted Halter Dress [23] ($398).
Huda Mustafa at the "Love Island USA" Reunion
Archive fashion is the way as per Mustafa's black velvet floral dress from Roberto Cavalli's fall/winter 2006 collection. It's now sold out, but these picks from Reformation would definitely be Huda-approved.
Get the Look: Reformation Tommen Two Piece [24] ($128, originally $428). Reformation Annabelle Silk Dress [25] ($448).
Hannah Fields at the "Love Island USA" Reunion
Fields proved that you can look red carpet-ready on a budget in this red frilly number from Outcast. It features romantic details, including a button closure at the halter neck, a plunging neckline, and asymmetric ruffles to grace every step.
Get the Look: Outcast Zoei Maxi Dress [26] ($119)
Naomi Parris [27] is an assistant shopping editor at Popsugar, based in New York. With over eight years of experience and previous roles held on the brand's Beauty and Operations teams, she enjoys telling stories that merge fashion, beauty, and Black culture. Naomi has also lent her skillful pen to Essence Girls United, Elle, Bustle, and Elite Daily. When she's not crafting shopping roundups, high-profile features, beauty op-eds, or trend guides, you can find Naomi behind her blog "Eli-Nay," where she inspires readers through style guides, cultural pieces, and innovative content on her Instagram.