Shop 20 of the Highest-Rated, Bestselling Shoes From Old Navy

Every editorial product is independently selected by our editors. If you buy something through our links, we may earn commission.

If you think you have to splurge to find shoes that are both fashion-forward and comfortable, prepare to be pleasantly surprised by the extensive range of options available at Old Navy. The affordably priced retailer has everything, from stylish espadrilles and dressy heels to slip-on sandals and comfortable sneakers for walking. To simplify your shoe-shopping experience, we've meticulously sifted through online reviews, handpicked our favorite styles, and even tested several pairs ourselves to curate a list of must-have shoes from Old Navy's expansive selection.

Whether you're seeking a timeless staple or experimenting with trendy styles without breaking the bank, we've got you covered. Our curated selection features a mix of editor-loved bestsellers and highly rated silhouettes, including our very own honest reviews. With significant markdowns, and some selling for as low as just $3, the combination of quality and affordability makes these options a smart investment. Keep reading to shop the 20 best Old Navy shoes and discover your new favorite pair for this season and beyond.

Best Ankle Boots From Old Navy
Old Navy

Best Ankle Boots From Old Navy

Faux Leather Block Heel Ankle Boots ($31, originally $45)

If you're looking to pick up a pair of shoes that will become an outfit staple this fall and winter, you can't go wrong with classic ankle boots. This faux-leather pair also comes in white and a cognac-brown color.

Best Clogs From Old Navy
Old Navy

Best Clogs From Old Navy

Old Navy Faux-Leather Sherpa-Lined Clogs ($28, originally $40)

These sherpa-lined faux leather clogs couldn't be cozier or cuter as we head into chillier months. They'd be the perfect shoes to slip into with jeans and a sweater or a long-sleeve, ankle-grazing dress.

Best Mary Jane Ballet Flats From Old Navy
oldnavy.gap.com

Best Mary Jane Ballet Flats From Old Navy

Old Navy Mary Jane Square-Toe Ballet Flats ($17, originally $25)

A classic pair of Mary Janes will never go out of style. This pair includes a square-shaped toe that adds sophistication. Ditch the heels and wear these with everything from trousers to dresses for a polished but comfortable look. They're available in pale pink.

Best Buckled Mules From Old Navy
oldnavy.gap.com

Best Buckled Mules From Old Navy

Old Navy Faux-Leather Loafer Mule Shoes ($24, originally $35)

These faux-leather mules have a buckle detail, making them an affordable dupe for a high-end version that looks very similar. They come in four color options, including a chocolate brown in faux-croc skin if you want even more texture.

Best Woven Mules From Old Navy
oldnavy.gap.com

Best Woven Mules From Old Navy

Old Navy Faux Leather Woven Mules ($16, originally $35)

These faux-leather woven mules are a new addition and perfect for transitioning from summer to fall. The woven design is breathable for warmer days but still offers plenty of foot coverage if you pair them with pants and a sweater for chillier weather. They come in three different colors, but we love the versatility that black offers.

Best Rain Boots From Old Navy
oldnavy.gap.com

Best Rain Boots From Old Navy

Old Navy Water-Repellent Pull-On Chelsea Rain Boots ($26, originally $40)

Do yourself a favor and invest in these chic water-repellant rain boots. Aside from keeping your toes dry, the matte PVC upper also helps resist stains, so muddy puddles really aren't a fair match. While you could go for classic black, we're very into this taupe option.

Best Loafers From Old Navy
oldnavy.gap.com

Best Loafers From Old Navy

Old Navy Faux-Leather Chunky-Heel Loafer Shoes ($23, originally $40)

These loafers will instantly elevate a pair of jeans or keep a dress feeling casual enough for daytime gallivanting. Between the cushioned footbed and chunky heel, they're surprisingly comfortable but sleek enough to be versatile. After wearing them all day, our contributing editor didn't want to take them off. Learn more via her review of the Faux-Leather Chunky-Heel Loafer Shoes.

Editor Quote: "These loafers are so comfortable that it's hard to believe the price tag — and I'm far from the only Old Navy shopper who thinks this. Scroll through the ratings section on Old Navy's website, and you'll see that nearly every review attests to how comfy they are. The footbed is made of a cushioned woven twill that I was able to wear for the full day without desperately craving to take them off — as is the case with many of my shoes." — Marisa Petrarca, contributing editor, Commerce

Best Mules From Old Navy
oldnavy.gap.com

Best Mules From Old Navy

Old Navy Faux-Leather Mule Shoes ($8, originally $30)

A mule might be the most versatile flat we can think of. These ones feel especially on-trend in this bone color. With more than 160 five-star reviews, they're a steal for the price.

Best Ballet Flats From Old Navy
oldnavy.gap.com

Best Ballet Flats From Old Navy

Textured-Knit Pointy-Toe Ballet Flats ($24, originally $35)

These ballet flats have a knitted texture and a pointed toe, which helps to elongate legs. Our editor tested them out and loved how versatile and comfortable they are. Read all about her experience in this Old Navy Textured-Knit Pointy-Toe Ballet Flats review.

Editor Quote: "The shoes are made from a breathable, textured-knit material that molds to your foot's shape, so it feels less like you're trying to squeeze your foot into a dense silhouette and more like you're sliding them into a classic slipper. Unlike traditional ballet flats, they also have a pointed-toe design versus the usual rounded top, which provides your toes with more breathing room and ensures they don't feel suffocated while you're walking. I love that they're so lightweight, I honestly forget they're on at all — even after I've been wearing them all day." — Kyley Warren, assistant editor, Commerce

Best Sneakers From Old Navy
oldnavy.gap.com

Best Sneakers From Old Navy

Old Navy Soft-Brushed Faux-Suede Sneakers ($21, originally $30)

These sneakers have over 1,300 reviews and an almost five-star rating, delivering both style and comfort. We love the mixed-material design, which features a faux suede upper and a contrasting faux-leather ankle collar.

Best T-Strap Flip-Flops From Old Navy
oldnavy.gap.com

Best T-Strap Flip-Flops From Old Navy

Old Navy T-Strap Flip-Flops ($5, originally $7)

You can't have an Old Navy shoe roundup without acknowledging this cult classic. These modernized versions of the popular classic come in three versatile shades. However, if you're a fan of the OG style, you can still grab the classic Old Navy Flip-Flop Sandals ($3, originally $5).

Best Double-Strap Slides From Old Navy
oldnavy.gap.com

Best Double-Strap Slides From Old Navy

Old Navy Double-Strap Slide Sandals (14, originally $20)

Whether you need a water-resistant sandal for gym and dorm showers or a cushioned sandal as light as air, these check both boxes. Available in four different options, including a fun leopard print, you'll be tempted to buy more than one. Our editor fell for the white pair and noticed they resemble a much pricier celeb-loved design. Get her full thoughts in this Double-Strap Slide Sandals review.

Editor Quote: "I'm really impressed with how comfortable they are thanks to their thick cushioning that your foot sinks into. That, teamed with how on-trend and easy to slip on they are, is why you'll find me wearing them just about everywhere this spring and summer." — MP

Best Cross-Strap Slides From Old Navy
oldnavy.gap.com

Best Cross-Strap Slides From Old Navy

Old Navy Faux-Leather Cross-Strap Sandals ($8, originally $20)

These sandals have received countless praises from Old Navy shoppers, who have deemed them the perfect everyday footwear due to their exceptional comfort, quality, and affordable price. One of our contributing editors is among those who love their look and feel; read her review of the Old Navy Faux-Leather Cross-Strap Sandals for more details.

Editor Quote: "In the product description, the brand describes these sandals as having a cushioned footbed, and in no way are they exaggerating. These slides feel like I'm walking on a cloud — or at least what I imagine walking on a cloud would feel like, anyway. Better yet, everything about them feels super durable, like they'll last me well beyond this summer." — MP

Best Braided Heels From Old Navy
oldnavy.gap.com

Best Braided Heels From Old Navy

Old Navy Square-Toe Braided Straw Cross-Strap Mule Sandals ($9, originally $40)

These cross-strap mules feature a trendy low-block heel that fuses style and comfort and a braided cross-strap upper that'll pair beautifully with your favorite jeans and trousers. Choose from two colors: this beige color called "Totally Natural" and "Black Jack."

Best Sandals With a Buckle From Old Navy
oldnavy.gap.com

Best Sandals With a Buckle From Old Navy

Old Navy Faux-Leather Double-Strap Metal-Hardware Sandals ($8, originally $25)

If you were to tell someone that these sandals are designer, they'd likely believe you without hesitation. One of the many things we adore about them is the adjustable strap, which allows you to customize the fit to perfection.

Best Lace-Up Espadrille Sandals From Old Navy
oldnavy.gap.com

Best Lace-Up Espadrille Sandals From Old Navy

Old Navy Textile Lace-Up Espadrille Sandals ($7, originally $40)

Whether you're packing for a European vacation or just want to look like you're on one, these lace-up espadrilles achieve the aesthetic. They're an online exclusive, so you won't find them in stores. The canvas laces allow you to adjust for comfort, and the jute soles add just enough cushiony height.

Best Espadrille Slides From Old Navy
oldnavy.gap.com

Best Espadrille Slides From Old Navy

Faux-Suede Espadrille Slide Sandals ($16, originally $30)

If you'd rather not fuss with laces but still love the look of an espadrille, try these espadrille slides. Offered in three colors, this rusty "copper moon" shade is ideal for adding a subtle pop of color. The sale price combined with a nearly-perfect rating means you don't have to think twice about whether or not to buy them.

Best Ruched Sandals From Old Navy
oldnavy.gap.com

Best Ruched Sandals From Old Navy

Old Navy Faux-Leather Ruched Sandals ($4, originally $23)

If you need easy slip-on sandals that can be dressed up or down, we have the pair for you. Between the ruffled texture and the electric-pink shade, these ruched ones make a statement without feeling too over the top. Available in six colors that range from a pretty mint to a pale pink, the toughest part is deciding which pair to buy.

Prefer heels? Check out the Old Navy Faux-Leather Strappy Block-Heel Mule Sandals ($15, originally $40).

Best Gladiator Sandals From Old Navy
oldnavy.gap.com

Best Gladiator Sandals From Old Navy

Old Navy Faux-Leather Lace-Up Gladiator Sandals ($6, originally $30)

A bohemian classic, these lace-up gladiator sandals will never go out of style and are an Old Navy bestseller. The gold tips offer a touch of glamour to this earthy style. Wear them with cropped, linen pants for a low-key look, or pair them with a dress.

Best Perforated Clogs From Old Navy
oldnavy.gap.com

Best Perforated Clogs From Old Navy

Old Navy Perforated Clog Shoes ($17, originally $25)

Light as air and water-resistant, these perforated clog shoes are a fantastic dupe for a popular style. Wear them to the beach or with socks and sweats for a laid-back look all year long. Offered in four colors, this taupe shade might be our favorite.