The burger: BBQ Bacon Burger
The situation: A patty topped with smoked mozzarella and BBQ-bacon mayonnaise.
Execution score: 2.5. We were eagerly anticipating a follow-up to the impressive showing that Bill's made at last year's New York Burger Bash. Sadly, that didn't happen: the burger, which was covered in a meager half slice of gluey white cheese, was far too greasy.
Photo: Anna Monette Roberts