Skip Nav
Cooking Basics
How to Pack a Perfect Mason Jar Salad
Food Video
This Fidget Spinner Is Made From Actual Pizza
Food Video
Taste the Rainbow With This No-Churn Skittles Ice Cream

Cool Off With World Famous Key Lime Pie

A few weeks ago, Ejmemis gave me a fabulous little tip that I just had to share with everyone. Like a true Florida girl, she loves her key lime pie with a zingy, creamy filling and crumbly, buttery crust. I may not be from Florida, but I love key lime pie, especially when the weather is warm.

Miami's Joe's Stone Crab restaurant, is famous for their amazing key lime pie and luckily for all of us who don't live there, they've recently released the recipe! To get the recipe for this refreshing dessert, all you have to do is

Key Lime Pie
From Joe's Stone Crab
Image Source

1 prepared 9-inch graham cracker pie crust, pre-baked according to directions, and cooled
3 large egg yolks, at room temperature
Grated zest of 2 Key limes, 1 teaspoon
1 14-ounce can sweetened condensed milk
2/3 cup fresh Key lime juice
1 cup cold heavy cream
1 tablespoon powdered sugar, or more, to taste
Thin slices of Key lime, for garnish

  1. Refrigerate baked and cooled pie shell until ready to use.
  2. Preheat oven at 350 F.
  3. In medium-size bowl, beat egg yolks and lime zest together with electric mixer on high speed until fluffy and well-aerated, about 5 minutes. Gradually add condensed milk and continue to beat until mixture is rather thick and fluffy, about 4 minutes.
  4. Lower speed and slowly add Key lime juice, mixing until just combined.
  5. Pour filling into chilled pie shell.
  6. Place pie on center oven rack and bake until set, about 10 minutes.
  7. Transfer pie to a wire rack and let cool thoroughly, then refrigerate until very cold, at least 2 hours.
  8. Freeze for 15 to 20 minutes; remove from freezer 20 minutes before serving.
  9. Before making whipped cream, chill mixing bowl and beaters for best results. Just before serving pie, beat heavy cream in mixer, add powdered sugar and continue to beat until nearly stiff, but not grainy. Do not overbeat.
  10. If serving entire pie at once, slather whipped cream over surface, then slice and serve. If serving only a few slices, garnish each with a dollop of whipped cream. Add very thin-sliced twists of fresh lime for additional garnish.

Serves 8.

Make Ahead: Unused portions can be frozen and, properly stored, Key lime pie will last several months in the freezer.

Join The Conversation
danakscully64 danakscully64 9 years
I made this and my boyfriend loved it! He ate almost the entire pie all by himself!
artsyvixen artsyvixen 9 years
Definitely going to try this. Have to squeeze in a few more key lime pie days before summer is gone!
danakscully64 danakscully64 9 years
Thank you for sharing :) I love hearing positive reviews before I make something.
mominator mominator 9 years
Just wanted to say thanks for the recipe because the pie was a HIT! Everyone loved it. It was dense yet creamy, tart but sweet. Perfect all the way around.
mominator mominator 9 years
Ok I made the Key Lime pie yesterday (Saturday) and I have made a big dinner today (Sunday) for my husband. I will come back this evening and let you know how it turned out. It is so hard not to go ahead and dig into it but I have to wait for hubby to get home and let him get into it first.
danakscully64 danakscully64 9 years
My boyfriend would fall over with joy if I made this for him! I should surprise him... I'm not a huge key lime fan, but a bite or two sounds good to me...
Ejmcmis Ejmcmis 9 years
OMG THANK YOU THANK YOU (I got a mention on sugar! how cool!). I have had the Joe's key lime pie, and it is AMAZING!!! that's the reason why I found this receipe and had to spread the word... I know that my plan for this weekend is try to make this and replicate all of that goodness!
ccy ccy 9 years
I was just thinking of Key Lime Pie on the week-end! Now I definately want some!
WillWorkForFood WillWorkForFood 9 years
I posted about this a while back on my site, but great job on getting the word about Joe's out! I grew up on Joe's (I lived about 5 minutes away...) The recipe has been out for a while, and if you haven't pick up the Joe's Stone Crab book! It's filled with history and recipes. I did have a tip about making the pie...if you're looking for a (somewhat) healthier version of it, buy a premade lowfat graham cracker crust and use lowfat or no-fat sweetened condensed milk. Oh, and if you haven't tried the Joe's Vinaigrette recipe, DO! It's so flippin' good. It's a chunky ingredient-filled recipe so you can serve this on bare lettuce or tomatoes and cucumbers. Go make it now!
bluestarlight bluestarlight 9 years
yummmy! Thank you - I'll make it
fashionhore fashionhore 9 years
I remember one summer my dad was home from work (vacation time) and he was grilling chicken drumsticks and a bunch of veggies for dinner. Well my sister asked for dessert and my dad didn't have anything--he went online, printed out the first pie recipe he found and made it. And sure enough it was a key lime pie, something my sister and I had never had before. It took a while to cool, so we ate it at like midnight on a hot summer night watching a Disney movie. He had never made it before, and I must say I have never had a better key lime pie in my life. That is my best memory of my sister and dad, to date.
ElizabethNicole ElizabethNicole 9 years
Thank you so much!! I love key lime pie and this recipe seems super easy!!
minnie minnie 9 years
Yum! I love new recipes! Thanks!
mominator mominator 9 years
I love key Lime Pie but not as much as my dear hubby. I am going to surprise him by making this for him this week. Thanks for sharing.
LaLaLaurie06 LaLaLaurie06 9 years
key lime pie is sooooo good.
ALSW ALSW 9 years
Not sure I've ever had Key Lime pie but this looks good!
CamillaCat CamillaCat 9 years
So summery!
intensebandgeek intensebandgeek 9 years
I'm definitely going to make this for my bf!
mellie_608 mellie_608 9 years
I saw this on the Food Network, Giada's Weekend Getaways, and it looked delicious! Thanks for the recipe!
angeldevilwings angeldevilwings 9 years
Love Key Lime pie!!!
kikidawn kikidawn 9 years
My b/f LOVES Key Lime Pie... definitely going to have to try this one.
oriav9 oriav9 9 years
Key Lime is sooo good. This Pic is yummy.
UrbanBohemian UrbanBohemian 9 years
Oh man! I want to try this one out!
KimmieFishie KimmieFishie 9 years
thank you - key lime is the best summer pie!
Best Slow-Cooker Recipes
Latin Barbecue Recipes
Pizza Fidget Spinner
Easy Brussels Sprouts Recipe
From Our Partners
Latest Food
All the Latest From Ryan Reynolds