Skip Nav

Everything Bagel Goat Cheese

Everything Bagel Goat Cheese Is Just the Appetizer Your Party Needs

The following post was originally featured on Cooking For Keeps and written by Nicole Shoemaker, who is part of POPSUGAR Select Food.

When it comes to bagels I'm picky.

They must be chewy on the outside, soft on the inside. Merely forming a piece of bread into a bagel doesn't cut it (I'm talking to you, Panera) — I see right through that. They must be toasted. I prefer loads of cream cheese to be slathered evenly between the top and the bottom. And they must be covered liberally in seasoning — preferably everything seasoning.

Kansas City doesn't have the greatest bagel market — we have Einstein brothers, which suffices and satisfies my short-term bagel craving, but my very favorite bagels are only attainable a handful of times a year as they come from a little town called Reisterstown near where my in-laws live.

After Kevin's parents talked up this particular bagel shop several times, I finally got to taste them for myself — life changing. They were perfectly chewy, oversize, and the best part? There were two tops. TWO TOPS, PEOPLE!!! Talk about a dream come true.

Of course in the two top game, the everything bagel wins by miles since every single bite is flavor-packed with garlic, onion, salt, sesame, and all things wonderful. Now, almost every single time we head to the East Coast my Mother-in-Law almost always has an everything bagel waiting for me upon our arrival — aren't I the luckiest?? (For other reasons as well.)

While my love of everything seasoning was strong before, trying this "perfect" bagel further solidified my obsession. I've transformed the "everything" flavor profile into mini pigs-in-a-blanket and fancied up my burgers with a dusting of the seasoning medley on the buns, but I'd yet to make it the star of the show.

When Laura posted these everything puff pastry cheese twists a few weeks back, my everything bagel imagination was reignited. So last weekend when I needed one more super easy hors d'oeuvre for one of my best friend's bridal showers, I immediately reached for this no-fuss appetizer.

And when I say this is no-fuss, I mean it. For your everything seasoning, you combine fennel seeds (you can toast them if you like, but it's not necessary), granulated garlic, granulated onion, poppy seeds, onion, and flaked sea salt together. You then take a store-bought goat cheese log and roll it in the seasoning, making sure every square inch of real estate is covered. Then — and this is the hard part — you put it on platter with a pretty cheese knife and your favorite crackers (I used rye chips) and let your guests dig in.

Simple, delicious, and the perfect crowd pleasure.

Now that I think about it, this would actually be perfect slathered on an everything bagel. Double the everything seasoning, double the fun.

Everything Bagel Goat Cheese

From Cooking For Keeps

Everything Bagel Goat Cheese


  1. 2 tablespoons sesame seeds
    2 tablespoons poppy seeds
    1 1/2 teaspoons coarse flaked sea salt
    2 teaspoons granulated garlic
    2 teaspoons granulated onion
    2 teaspoons fennel seed
    1 10-ounce log of goat cheese
    Crackers, for serving


  1. On a plate, combine seasonings. Roll goat cheese in seasoning. Let set for 15 minutes at room temperature before serving.
  2. Serve with crackers.
Image Source: Cooking For Keeps
Latest Recipes, Menus, Food & Wine
All the Latest From Ryan Reynolds