Skip Nav

Homemade Salted Caramel Oatmeal Cream Pie Recipe

Homemade Salted Caramel Oatmeal Cream Pies Guaranteed to Satisfy Your Sweet Tooth

The following post was originally featured on Cooking For Keeps and written by Nicole Shoemaker, who is part of POPSUGAR Select Food.

One of my biggest character flaws is the ability to find blame on someone other than myself, no matter what. Kevin receives the brunt of all the displaced blame, and it's become quite the ongoing joke in our relationship, so much so, that whenever anything goes awry, Kevin will immediately ask how we can trace fault back to him. Luckily, I've realized this shortcoming in myself, and I'm happy to report that I'll now accept at least twenty percent of the blame . . .

One thing I know I can absolutely blame on Kevin is my unwavering sweet tooth. Before he came along, I could pass up any cookie, piece of candy, or chocolate that came my way, and now, I'm like a weak five year old who can't keep her hands out of the cookie jar. Pregnancy only accelerated my love of all things sweet, and I indulged in one of my very favorite confections — an oatmeal cream pie — at our neighborhood bakery at least once a week.

Even with my absent sweet tooth as a kid, I was always a sucker for an oatmeal cream pie. Back then, it was the Little Debbie packaged variety, which I was totally content with up until I had the real deal at my girlfriend's wedding last year — now, I'm never going back.

At $3.95 a pop, my bi-weekly oatmeal cream pie habit has become quite an expense in this budget-minded gal, so I set out to make my own version at home. Plus, why have two oatmeal cream pies a week when I can have a dozen at my disposal??

Now, I'll level with you; this is not an easy recipe. This is not a quick recipe. There are three components; the cookie, the frosting, and the salted caramel. All made from scratch, all essential to the final product.

The cookie recipe is surprisingly enough a VERY liberal adaptation of the recipe on the back of the oatmeal container — since I'm not an avid baker, I used the recipe as a subtle guideline on measurements. I added in some molasses since I was using light brown sugar, some instant pudding for softness, and shortening, because, frankly, I was curious how it would change the texture.

Luckily, my curiosity paid off, because the end cookie is chewy in the middle, super crisp on the outside, and the perfect thickness to encase a sweet and salty cream cheese and salted caramel filling.

A few notes about the cookies. You MUST chill the dough. This is essential; the cookies are already on the thin side, and if you don't chill the dough, they will just spread and melt on to the pan. I'd suggest forming them and then chilling them overnight, but you can also pop them in the freezer for 45 minutes if you're in a hurry.

The filling is a super easy cream cheese frosting you can throw together in under ten minutes. You just whip up a little bit of softened cream cheese and butter, then slowly add in your vanilla and powdered sugar.

For the salted caramel . . . I know, making homemade caramel can be daunting, BUT it's really super easy. Add your sugar to a cold pan, then turn the heat on a medium-low, once the sugar begins to caramelize on the edges and melts, I start to stir. When all of the sugar melts and is an amber color, I add in my butter, stir until it's completely melted, and then take it off the heat and add in the cream. The mixture will sputter and boil, just keep stirring and it will eventually settle down and come together.

All that's left is to assemble — one cookie gets slathered with cream cheese frosting, then drizzled with the homemade caramel, and topped with another cookie.

If you don't eat them all right away (you probably will), keep them chilled in the fridge in an airtight container and bring them out about 30 minutes before you serve them.

Homemade Salted Caramel Oatmeal Cream Pies

From Cooking For Keeps

Homemade Salted Caramel Oatmeal Cream Pie Recipe

Ingredients

  1. Oatmeal Cookies
    3/4 cup unsalted butter, softened (1 1/2sticks)
    1/4 cup (4 tbsp.) vegetable shortening
    1 1/4 cup light brown packed brown sugar
    3/4 cup white sugar
    2 eggs
    2 tsp. vanilla bean paste (or extract)
    1 tbsp. dark molasses
    1 1/4 cup all-purpose flour
    2 1/2 cups quick-cooking oats
    2 tbsp. instant vanilla pudding mix
    1 tsp. baking soda
    1/4 tsp. baking powder
    1/2 tsp. cinnamon
    1/4 tsp. kosher salt
    1/2 cup golden raisins
  1. Cream Cheese Frosting
    1/4 cup unsalted butter, softened
    1/4 cup cream cheese, softened (you can use 1/3 reduced fat)
    2 tsp. vanilla bean paste (or extract if you can't find paste)
    2 1/2 cups powdered sugar
  1. Caramel
    1/2 cup white sugar
    2 1/2 tbsp. butter
    1/2 cup heavy cream
    Kosher salt

Directions

Cookies:

  1. In the bottom of a stand mixer, add butter, shortening, brown sugar, and white sugar. Beat until light and fluffy, about 2 minutes. Add in egg, vanilla, and molasses; beat another minute until smooth. If needed, scrape down sides with spatula and beat again until smooth.
  2. Add in flour, oatmeal, instant pudding mix, baking powder, baking soda, cinnamon, salt, and raisins. Mix just until combined.
  3. Form dough into 2-tablespoon balls, place on a greased baking sheet (you do not need to space them since they will be transferred to a container), and VERY slightly flatten top. Chill until firm. Transfer to an airtight container and chill for 24 hours.
  4. Preheat oven to 350°F. After dough has chilled, grease a baking sheet with nonstick cooking spray or line with a Silpat. Cook six cookies at a time (cookies will spread) for 11 minutes (no more); cookies will not look done, but they will be. Cool on baking sheet for 2 minutes, then CAREFULLY use a spatula to transfer to a cooling rack. Repeat with remaining cookies. Cool completely before assembling.

Frosting:

  1. Beat butter, cream cheese, and vanilla together until light and fluffy. Add in powdered sugar, 1/2 cup at a time, until smooth.

Caramel:

  1. Add sugar to the bottom of a medium saucepan. Turn the heat on medium low and wait for the sugar to start melt. Once the sugar starts to turn an amber color or the edges begin to melt, stir with a metal spoon. Continue to stir every 10-15 seconds until all the sugar is melted and an amber color. Once all the sugar has melted, add in butter; stir until combined. Turn the heat off and add in cream. The mixture will sputter and boil; just continue to stir until the cream is incorporated. Transfer to a mason jar and cool completely.

To assemble:

  1. Spread 2-3 tablespoons of frosting on one cookie. Drizzle with caramel, sprinkle with kosher salt, and top with anther cookie.
  2. Serve immediately or store in an airtight container in the fridge. Let them come to room temperature before serving.
Image Source: Cooking For Keeps
Latest Recipes, Menus, Food & Wine
All the Latest From Ryan Reynolds