Skip Nav
Food Video
These Chocolate Dragon Eggs Have a Colorful Surprise Inside
Get the Dish
Cinnamon Roll Ice Cream Bowls Give a Whole New Meaning to Dessert For Breakfast
Fast and Easy
20 Reasons Avocado Toast Is the Sexiest Snack on the Planet

Melissa: "I've Never Received Criticism That Harsh in My Life"

Melissa: "I've Never Received Criticism That Harsh in My Life"

This week we watched as two chefs got the axe on Top Chef. Yesterday I had the chance to speak with both Melissa and Eugene. It was interesting to hear the contestants' perspectives of the new judge, Toby Young.

First up: Melissa. She's truly believes her food is imaginative and creative and is excited for the upcoming opening of her new restaurant Happy Noodle House in Boulder, CO.

To see what she had to say about the competition,


On her losing dish: I honestly wish I had done an entirely different dish. Looking back, I would have been better off with something different. If someone doesn't appreciate what you are trying to do, you do something different. But, no — there was no time. When I was making the dish, I was focused and proud of it. What it came down to is that the judges didn't like it. Like I said, I just should have done something totally different.

On Toby Young's "cat food" criticism: Well, first, I think Toby was hired to be harsh, dramatic, and say it how it is. I think he could have said things a little differently, but we all had to take it. Chefs get criticized for their food. It is what it is. I've never received criticism that harsh in my life. You never think your food is going to not be liked. You made it for a reason. It was really hard to take that level of criticism. I had never even heard of Toby Young until they brought him on the show. But if the producers got him, I was sure he knew what he was doing.

On watching her peers critique her dish: Oh man, when we had to watch them critique our food! I think it was very hard watching them right after eating it. It's different when you hear a critique later. They choose their words more carefully, but in the moment when they blurt out stuff, it's a lot harsher.

On being in the bottom three multiple times: As it goes along you get more and more used to dealing with the judges, but no matter what it's hard to hear the criticism. No matter where you are in life it sucks to hear criticism. But it's the only way to get better: take it in and listen to what they have to say.

On Tom calling her unimaginative and lacking creativity: I've gotten over it, but it still sits with me. My imagination and creativity is something I've always been known for, so it's hard to hear that they didn't see it. I would really like to email Tom and figure out what he was saying. I want to talk to him about it. I care more about Tom's critique than Toby's.

On Bravo's portrayal of her personality: I'm happy the way I was portrayed, but I would have liked to have won. I wish I didn't leave when I left. I wanted to win.


Join The Conversation
LemonOut LemonOut 8 years
Whatever Melissa. I find her claims that here cooking is generally more interesting hard to believe, as she was consistently criticized for boring, uninspired food. She seems to rationalize and deny most of the criticism of her cooking.
doogirl doogirl 8 years
I don't like the new judge, it's like he's being mean simply to be mean, it's not fun to watch. Even Collicio looked like he was rolling his eyes when that Toby guy was talking. I think he's one of those people that other people are afraid of, because they don't want to hear what he might say. He's one little tiny person for goodness sakes! As for Melissa, she just seemed really nervous all the time. And her food didn't seem interesting, the hot shrimp, the fish tacos, maybe she should stay away from seafood!
LaurenG22 LaurenG22 8 years
ewwww she has a horrible personality (as portrayed on the show) and I would never eat anything she makes.
mannylove mannylove 8 years
Meh...I won't miss her
kia kia 8 years
I have not watched the show yet but there is a little buzz here in Boulder about the two contestants on the show this season.
CaterpillarGirl CaterpillarGirl 8 years
she has never heard of Toby so his criticsm isnt valid i guess? She failed, it was obvious she wasnt going to win, I mean throughout the competition till now she was bumbling through, making terrible dishes (super hot shrimp anyone?) and not choosing to step bye bye
ilanac13 ilanac13 8 years
i know that melissa says that she can do much better, and i wonder if it was just being on TV. I feel like she had nerves and didn't really get to perform well in the kitchen. i do agree with what she said about the new judge though. he's like simon from AI
Zeke Smith Outed on Survivor April 2017
Bethenny Frankel and Fredrik Eklund Show on Bravo
Her Universe Wonder Woman Activewear Line
47 Meters Down Exclusive Clip
From Our Partners
Latest Food
All the Latest From Ryan Reynolds