Skip Nav
Food Video
These Chocolate Dragon Eggs Have a Colorful Surprise Inside
Food Reviews
Boxed Rosé Is Here to Get You Day-Drunk With Dignity All Summer Long
Get the Dish
Cinnamon Roll Ice Cream Bowls Give a Whole New Meaning to Dessert For Breakfast

Thanksgiving Tip: How to Select the Right Turkey

You may have perfected your Thanksgiving menu, including a mouth-watering recipe for Herb-Butter Turkey, but do you know how to choose the perfect bird to serve at your big feast? Have you figured out how big it should be? Do you know the difference between frozen and fresh? If you'd like the answer to these questions, then keep on reading, I've compiled a few tips to help you out.

  • To figure out how big of a turkey you should buy, a good rule of thumb is about 1 lb. per person, more if you want leftovers and less if those people are children (unless they're children with adult appetites!). If the turkey is prestuffed, up the amount to 1.75–2 lbs. per person.
  • Generally speaking, the younger the bird, the better the flavor and tenderness. Fryer (also called roaster) turkeys are less than four months old and the most tender turkey you can buy. Young turkeys are four to eight months old and have soft, smooth skin. A yearling is a 12-month-old turkey and is reasonably tender. A mature (also called old) is one that is older than 15 months. The meat is tough and it is not well suited for roasting.
  • Discover a few more tips, just

  • Although a fresh turkey costs more than a frozen, it's generally considered a superior bird. Fresh turkeys have never been cooled to a temperature lower than 26°F, whereas frozen turkeys are flash frozen. If you buy a fresh turkey, try to arrange to pick it up as close to the eating date as possible. Storing a fresh turkey in your freezer may cause it to deteriorate quickly (home freezers don't have the same cooling capability as commercial ones).
  • Some other labels you might see on a turkey include: smoked — ready to eat as the process has cured and cooked the meat; organic — one that is only fed organic feed; natural — no artificial ingredients or coloring are added; self-basting — injected with various ingredients that keep the turkey moist while roasting.

If you have any great tips or questions on how to select the perfect turkey, let us know in the comments below!


Join The Conversation
aimeeb aimeeb 9 years
My sis does this...
aimeeb aimeeb 9 years
PetitLapinVegan PetitLapinVegan 9 years
Thanksgiving for the Birds by Colleen Patrick-Goudreau Humans are funny birds. We get so wrapped up in habits, comfort zones, and traditions that sometimes we forget who we are, what we care about, and why we even do what we do. Thanksgiving is one such instance, sadly exemplified by its alternative name: "Turkey Day." Thanksgiving is meant to be a day when we celebrate the bounty of the harvest, pause in gratitude for the abundance most of us experience, and share what we have with others. Most people don't stop to think about the nearly 300 million birds that are killed each year in the United States, just to satisfy our taste buds. Of this number, 45 million are killed for Thanksgiving alone. As someone who teaches vegetarian cooking classes, I've seen many people turn away from meat, dairy and eggs and embrace the array of delicious, nutritious plant-based foods available to us. I've also seen them change the lens through which they view the world, which I think is critical for shedding the comfort zones of the past and creating new ones. Some people have a real fear that they will no longer have satisfying, filling meals -- especially on Thanksgiving. I can say with confidence that they can put their fears to rest. Our Thanksgiving feast every year is full of comfort foods galore, prepared with organic ingredients from local farms: mashed potatoes with mushroom gravy, bread & nut stuffing, mashed rutabagas, cranberries with pecans, stuffed acorn squash, corn bread, Brussels sprouts, corn, peas, pumpkin pie with cashew cream, and apple pie. This was our menu last year, and I'm sure I've left something out. Indeed, there is no dearth of food on our table on this special day, as we share it with our closest friends and family. For those who have never met them, turkeys are magnificent animals, full of spunk and spark and affection, with individual personalities and charms. These animals, who have been abused and discarded by human beings, whose beaks and toes have been mutilated, and whose genetically overgrown bodies are susceptible to heart disease and leg deformities, still display immense affection towards humans. They are incredibly curious and follow you wherever you go, and their wonderful vocalizations include an array of clucks, purrs, coos, and cackles. Turkeys love to be caressed, and people often remark that they respond just like their own dogs and cats. Turkeys even make a purring sound when they are content, and not until you've had a hen fall asleep under your arm have you lived. She will literally melt under your touch, relax her body, and begin to close her eyes, softly clucking all the while. It's a sight to see, and I'm moved every time I have the privilege to witness it. Some turkeys are more affectionate than others, climbing into your lap and making themselves as comfortable as can be. At an animal sanctuary I frequent, a particularly friendly turkey became known for her propensity to hug. As soon as you crouched down, she would run over to you, press her body against yours, and crane her head over your shoulders, clucking all the while. It's amazing how so generous a hug can be given by something with no arms. They're not all saints, but some are heroes. One turkey became my personal protector when I was trying to clean a barn and was continually accosted by a particularly rude and aggressive bird. Each time the aggressor would begin to close in on me, my hero would waddle over and get between me and his barn-mate. It was remarkable, and it happened over and over (turkeys are very persistent). What made this scene even more touching was the fact that these toms suffered from bumble foot, abscesses on the footpads that resemble corns, a common occurrence in domesticated turkeys. Between their grotesquely large breasts and inflamed feet, turkeys walk very awkwardly and with a lot of effort. I was very touched that such an effort was made on my behalf. I grew up eating turkeys' breasts, turkeys' legs, and turkeys' wings, and I'm still making amends to these extraordinary animals. I believe we're able to mutilate certain animals for our gustatory pleasure because we don't have relationships with them. We've never meet them face to face. Once I met a turkey, I was never the same again. Once I began to celebrate Thanksgiving as turkey-free holiday, I learned for the first time what "Happy Turkey Day" really means.
Home Home 9 years
we just ordered a free range organic heritage turkey. We have to drive up to Petaluma to pick it up next weekend!
michichan michichan 9 years
Sounds like a lot. Someone wants leftovers.
Bettyesque Bettyesque 9 years
This is good stuff! I posted a few different Turkey ideas... check them out sugas!
terryt18 terryt18 9 years
Geez, I knew I shouldn't have bought the turkey labeled "old."
mamaseacat mamaseacat 9 years
So the "older" turkeys must be what we get for free at Albertson's. Got it! Thanks for the tips.
fragiletearz fragiletearz 9 years
Yay I'm doing Tday dinner at my house this year and I wasn't sure what size turkey to buy, this helps!
UrbanBohemian UrbanBohemian 9 years
I guess the turkeys that are +15 mos get a free ride then!
Pakelpen Pakelpen 9 years
What about Heritage Turkeys? Like the ones at
Pamukkale Hot Springs
How to Easily Roast Red Peppers For Beginners
Patti LaBelle's Sweet Potato Pie Recipe
Easy Brussels Sprouts With Bacon Recipe
From Our Partners
Latest Food
All the Latest From Ryan Reynolds