Organic Midnight Moo ($3)
Trader Joe's Organic Midnight Moo is back! This beloved chocolate syrup is a years-old Trader Joe's product that was discontinued in 2016. After the unexpected hiatus, it's finally back and ready to be drizzled into chocolate milk, on top of ice cream, onto waffles, and with whatever else you want to eat the fat-free syrup with. Far superior to other store-bought chocolate syrups, this one is made with high-quality ingredients you can taste, like organic vanilla extract.