The 10 Best Sofas to Shop From Castlery — According to Our Editors

Updated on 2/13/2024 at 11:15 AM

Castlery

Every editorial product is independently selected by our editors. If you buy something through our links, we may earn commission.

Sofa shopping has evolved beyond the days of having to choose between whatever is in stock at big-box stores or having to pay a ton of money and wait for longer shipping times for custom pieces. Direct-to-consumer furniture brands have swooped in to disrupt the most frustrating aspects of online shopping, especially when making a purchase as monumental as a sofa. One of our favorite DTC brands with an incredible selection of comfortable sofas is Castlery. The brand focuses on creating modern, cool, and practical pieces that range from beds to storage. They incorporate trends, but don't rely on them. Instead, their quality pieces are built to last, all at fair prices.

What to Look For When Buying a Couch From Castlery

There are lots of factors to consider when buying a sofa, like size, fabric, style, function, and cost. For guidance on the details that matter most, we tapped interior design experts Bradley Odom and Jennifer Hunter for their best sofa-shopping tips. When it comes to materials, Odom looks for cushions that have sinuous springs wrapped in foam and down. "No matter how many times you sit in one spot, the cushion will always bounce back," he says. If you're tight on square footage, Odom advises searching for sofas with narrow arms. "Wide arms add to the larger footprint without adding to the usable seat space," he points out. Hunter prefers sleeker frames and sofas with bench seating. "It tricks the eye into appearing longer by not breaking up the seats," she says. If you want your sofa to perform double duty as a sleeper, Owens has an invaluable tip to make sure your space can accommodate it. "Pay close attention to the dimensions of the sleeper mechanism when fully extended," she warns.

Material also plays a vital role; durable fabrics like polyester are easy to clean and perfect for kids or pet owners. If you want an alternative to fabric, leather sofas have a timeless look and spills can easily be wiped. That said, they are prone to scratching, which may be a problem if you have pets. Most importantly, don't forget to measure your space and pay close attention to the sofa's dimensions. This way, you can determine if you need a smaller silhouette like a loveseat, or if you have room for a large, cozy sectional. Luckily, Castlery has all of these options and beyond.

Is Castlery a Good Furniture Brand?

Constructed with quality upholstery like top-grain leathers and performance fabrics, Castlery's sofas not only look and feel good, but are also made to last. Many of their sofa styles offer hardwood frames and sinuous springs for a solid foundation that bounces back, no matter how much use it gets. With fill that ranges from feather blends for cloud-like plushness to high-quality foam for resilience, their cushions are comfortable yet supportive.

How We Make Our Sofa Selections

As sofa connoisseurs, our POPSUGAR editors have tested dozens in their own homes with many of our favorite sofas being from Castlery. If you're in the market for a sofa, we've curated our top picks from Castlery based on our editor product reviews, expert tips, and market research to help you choose the best one for you.

— Additional reporting by Anvita Reddy and Kyley Warren

The Best Affordable Sofa From Castlery

Castlery Ethan Armless 2-Seater Sofa ($899, originally $1,049)

If you need to accommodate overnight guests but are tight on square footage, this armless sofa is a fantastic option. Because of its open-ended frame, your guests won't have to worry about squeezing into a tight-fitting couch with uncomfortable arm rests. The midcentury design offers loads of style, and we love the sleek gray shade.

What we love:

The stylish design makes a statement, but it's also comfy and functional.
The armless style doubles as a functional sleeping alternative for guests.

Who it's best for:

This couch is ideal for someone who loves midcentury design but wants the function of a modern couch.
The smaller design is great for tiny spaces, or even as an extra sleeping space in an office or spare room.

Who should avoid it:

The model is designed as a two-seater, meaning it doesn't offer quite as much seating space as a larger sectional or couch.
This sofa is on the firmer side, so if you prefer a sofa you can sink into, this isn't it.

Castlery Ethan Armless 2-Seater Sofa

From

$899

$1,049 Now 14% off

The Best Cloud-Like Couch From Castlery

Castlery Dawson Sofa ($2,098)

If you're in the market for a pillowy, cloud-like sofa, then try the Dawson Sofa from Castlery. It has a modern and boxy design with stylish curves at the edges of the seat cushions. Its soft, deep cushions make it ideal for lounging. It's also an editor-favorite pick, and you can read more details in this Castlery Dawson Sofa review. This option is pretty versatile, but the collection has other sizes in this style, too. Because it arrives in just two boxes, assembly is easy.

What we love:

"It's a truly lounge-worthy couch that I just love relaxing in while watching movie; I even work on it with my laptop. The deep cushions are thick and easy to sink right while still offering support and not feeling flimsy," says our former editor.
This stylish and comfortable option looks like a high-end designer piece without the price tag to match.

Who it's best for:

This couch is great for someone looking for that trendy cloud look.
The modular design comes in two pieces, so it's ideal for moving into an apartment or just a small space.

Who should avoid it:

If you're prone to spills and want to avoid stains, you might want to go for a different option that has darker color choices.
If you need a sofa that provides lots of support, you might want a firmer option.

Castlery Dawson Sofa

From

$2,098

The Best Modular Sofa From Castlery

Castlery Auburn Performance Fabric Chaise Sectional Sofa ($3,177)

The Auburn sofa is one of Castlery's more elevated options with a curved design and trend-driven boucle fabric. It's well worth the splurge, especially since it looks more expensive than it is, and is actually functional and comfortable, rather than just a show piece. One of our editors put it to the test as well and raves that it made her living room look luxe.

"Its clean-lined look completely revamped my space, but it's built for everyday use. I can comfortably lounge in its deep seats and curl up for a movie night, host my friends and make them feel like they entered a swanky hotel lobby, and just have my home feel like a slice of luxury," she says. Read more in her review of the Castlery Auburn Sofa.

What we love:

"It was exactly what I was looking for in terms of the design — it's elevated and modern with its rounded silhouette, but the bouclé brings out the softness and cozy feel," says one of our editors.
The upholstery performance-grade and spill-resistant, so it's perfect for those with kids and pets.

Who it's best for:

This sofa is great for those looking to elevate their space but need something functional. The sofa's curved silhouette is best suited for a more contemporary space.
Its modular design lends itself to being an ideal fit for your space, since you can also completely customize the seating pieces and add storage as well.

Who should avoid it:

If you want something that delivers that sinking-in, cloud-like feel, consider the other options in this guide.

The Details: Width: 121.9 inches | Height: 30.1 inches | Depth: 36-65.4 inches | Upholstery: spill-resistant boucle polyester fabric | Color Options: 2 | Fill: Foam-, fibre-, and pocket spring-filled seat cushions; foam- and fibre-filled back

Castlery Auburn Performance Fabric Chaise Sectional Sofa

From

$3,177

The Best Couch From Castlery

Castlery Hamilton Sofa ($1,599, originally $1,899)

When our editor sat down in Castlery's Hamilton Sofa for the first time, she didn't want to get up. "I have a bad back, but the cushions are firm enough to keep everything aligned while also making me feel like I'm wrapped up in a warm cocoon," she said. Get more details in her review of the Castlery Hamilton Sofa. If you like this sofa but want a larger option, they sell sectionals in the Hamilton style as well.

What we love:

The sofa has deep seats that are filled with foam, fiber, and pocket springs. It's also built with sinuous springs, a construction detail Odom highly recommends.

Who it's best for:

As our editor mentions in her review, this is a good option if you prefer more back support.
The fabric is polyester and acrylic, a combination our editor mentioned was easy to wipe clean in her review. If you're prone to spills or have kids or pets, this sofa is a good choice. You can also remove the cushions to vacuum up stray crumbs.

Who should avoid it:

This sofa is low to the ground, which makes it more difficult to get up. If you prefer sofas with higher seating, this might not be the one for you.

Castlery Hamilton Sofa

From

$1,599

$1,899 Now 16% off

POPSUGAR Photography | Krista Jones

The Best Low-Profile Sofa From Castlery

Castlery Todd Side Chaise Sofa ($1,659, originally $1,849)

The modern, boxy vibe of this side chaise sofa makes it an editor favorite. Our former editor tested it out in her home and fell in love with its style and cushioned arms. "Hands down, my favorite thing about the sofa is the way it looks. It has a sleek and modern vibe that totally completes my living room and fits into my style," she says. Get her full thoughts on the sofa in this Castlery Todd Side Chaise Sofa review.

What we love:

Though it has a structured form, it's more comfortable than it looks. Our favorite feature is the square armrest, which acts and feels like a pillow for you to rest your head on.

Who it's best for:

The low-profile look is great for small spaces, such as an apartment.

Who should avoid it:

Because it's a lower-to-the-ground silhouette, you have to lean down to sit in it, so those with back problems might want to look at another option.

Castlery Todd Side Chaise Sofa

From

$1,659

$1,849 Now 10% off

The Best Modern Sectional From Castlery

Castlery Pebble Chaise Sectional Sofa ($1,999)

Large sectionals that don't overwhelm a room are hard to come by, but the sleek silhouette of this Castlery sectoonal isn't the least bit bulky. Like Odom points out, the thin arms on this sectional don't take up usable seat space, so every inch is maximized. The thin legs also create more negative space, which tricks the eye. It's available in both a right- or left-facing chaise, so you can find a model that will work in your space.

What we love:

The sleek frame maximizes the amount of seating without hogging precious square footage.

Who it's best for:

The color choices are versatile, and the dark shades are ideal for those who are worried about stains.

Who should avoid it:

If you have a tiny living room, you might want to shop a smaller option, like a two- or three-seater.

Castlery Pebble Chaise Sectional Sofa

From

$1,999

The Best Midcentury-Modern Sofa From Castlery

Castlery Madison Chaise Sectional Sofa ($1,759, originally $2,199)

If you're looking for a more formal silhouette, this chaise sectional sofa delivers with its tufted bench seat and rolled accent pillows. It comes in several colors, in addition to the choice between fabric and leather. We can't resist this vibrant gold shade, but you can pick a neutral shade too. You can even tack on a matching ottoman ($339) if you like.

What we love:

It has that midcentury look while still feeling contemporary enough for a modern home.
It also comes in leather options as well.

Who it's best for:

This couch is great for someone who loves tufted-style sofas but wants the versatility of a sectional.
The plush cushions and little side pillows not only look cute but are also cozy. They're perfect for curling up with a good book.

Who should avoid it:

This petite sectional is a good choice for small spaces, but if you need something bigger, there are options that can sit even more people.

Castlery Madison Chaise Sectional Sofa

From

$1,759

$2,199 Now 20% off

Castlery Madison Ottoman

From

$339

The Best Bouclé Sofa From Castlery

Castlery Lucas Performance Bouclé Sofa ($1,799)

We love the soft feel of bouclé, but it has a reputation for being hard to clean. Enter the brilliance of this performance bouclé sofa from Castlery. This cozy couch is perfect for someone who loves minimal design and loads of texture, but doesn't want to have to be paranoid about spills.

What we love:

The cool Scandinavian design makes a statement without being impractical.

Who it's best for:

This couch is great for someone who is looking for a sofa with a different type of texture and a unique silhouette.

Who should avoid it:

The size is on the smaller side and would be great for someone who lives in an apartment or has a small living room.

Castlery Lucas Performance Bouclé Sofa

From

$1,799

The Best Sofa With a Chaise Lounge From Castlery

Castlery Verona Bumper Chaise Sectional Sofa ($2,259, originally $2,499)

We love this chaise sectional for its sophistication and simplicity. Luxe details like the gold legs add loads of elegance while still maintaining a minimal look. It also comes in dark gray.

What we love:

This couch offers thick and plush cushions that are perfect for lounging on and a long chaise that you can lie back on or use as extra seating for guests.

Who it's best for:

This sofa is stylish, comfortable, and versatile and is a great choice for someone with a larger budget.
If you have a larger family or love to entertain, this is a good option seeing as there's plenty of seating.

Who should avoid it:

If you have a tighter space, you should go for a more compact sectional or a sofa with fewer seats.
Its low-slung frame means you need to bend down lower to sit, and it can be harder to get up. If you prefer something that is higher off the ground, this one might not be the best fit.
If you have a smaller budget, you might want to consider one of Castlery's less expensive sofas.

Castlery Verona Bumper Chaise Sectional Sofa

From

$2,259

$2,499 Now 10% off

The Best Leather Sofa From Castlery

Castlery Jonathan Leather Extended Sofa ($3,639, originally $3,847)

This leather sofa is chunky, modular seating at its finest. The generous armrests are so comfy, you can either lean back on them while lounging on the sofa or perch on them. Made with buttery, top-grain leather, it's a durable sofa choice.

What we love:

This low couch exudes a modern, cool style. Its solid silhouette is a great anchor to any room.
It comes in a variety of configurations, including armless options and ones with an ottoman, making it ideal for any space.

Who it's best for:

If you prefer a more structured couch, this is the piece for you.
The sofa also arrives fully assembled, so it's great if you don't want the hassle of putting it together.

Who should avoid it:

It's on the firmer side, so if you're someone who likes to sink into your couch, this might not be the piece for you.
If you have dogs or cats, you might want to avoid this sofa since leather can scratch.

Castlery Jonathan Leather Extended Sofa

From

$3,639

$3,847 Now 5% off