Andy Cohen comes up with the craziest games on Watch What Happens Live. The Bravo host played a hilarious (and totally bizarre) game of "Better Pluck Next Time" with guests Gloria Estefan and Leah Remini on Nov. 4, after he heard that Gloria prides herself on being a good eyebrow groomer.

For every Jennifer Lopez [1] trivia question BFF Leah answered incorrectly, Gloria would pluck one of Andy's infamously bushy brow hairs. Spoiler alert: Leah forgot what NYC college J Lo attended and what year she wore that infamous sheer Versace dress [2] to the Grammys, and Andy suffered the consequences. Gloria did a great job shaping Andy's brows delicately and without inflicting pain. Watch the fun game play out in its entirety above, then take a look back at all of Leah's girl Jennifer's best outfits of the year [3].