Thanks to Jonathan Taylor Thomas's 34th birthday today, we are big-time reminiscing about our favorite '90s heartthrobs. Not only did we see all their movies, sing all their songs, and learn all their dance moves, but we also managed to cover every last inch of our bedroom walls and school notebooks with pictures of the teen stars. We've rounded up the best, most cheesy '90s posters of everyone from Devon Sawa to Joey Lawrence to help you remember your first loves. The poses are even funnier now that some of these heartthrobs, like Leonardo DiCaprio and Jared Leto, are serious award winners. Check it out!