Skip Nav
Make a Relationship a Choice, Not a Goal — Here's What You Need to Do First
18 Breakup Quotes That Will Make You Feel So Much Better
Solange Knowles
This Bride's Solange-Inspired Wedding Will Make Your Jaw Hit the Floor

Dear Poll: Would You Ever Date Brothers?

The Afflecks — they're both talented, good looking and wealthy, so how could you choose between the two — or do you have to? Ladies, tell me, would you ever date brothers? If it didn't work out with one of them and you started developing feelings for the other one, be honest, would you ever go for the brother of your ex?


Join The Conversation
Linny Linny 9 years
i wonder how a brother could date his own brother's ex. that does not seem right to me. if i had a relationship with a guy and my sister dated him after i did, i'd be pissed. katerkins- my mom dated her best friend's brother and they got married (and had me) and they've been together forever (26 years). that's kind of breaking a rule though.
Katerkins Katerkins 9 years
I have a major crush on my best guy friend's older brother. Even that's pretty awkward...
groem6 groem6 9 years
Dating brothers would seem alot like incest to me. When I've dated men who had brothers, I've had a real "brother (in law)" feeling about their brothers. Also, having two sisters, I know I could never be intimate with someone who also had done so with one of my sisters.. Eew.
rileycantina rileycantina 9 years
it is kind of a common theme in the movies. dan in real life is the most recent and by the end you just end up thinking, is the family ok with this? family stone was another. and that one was especially weird since the two brothers switched girlfriends. tres gross.
whenturtlesfly whenturtlesfly 9 years
when i first read this question i thought of "while you were sleeping." but i guess sandra bullock never dated peter gallagher. sorry, tangent!
lala788 lala788 9 years
no way, too weird
melda melda 9 years
after reading all comments..
demeter demeter 9 years
Definitely not.
aimeeb aimeeb 9 years
Too weird!
HoneyLuv89 HoneyLuv89 9 years
no way. i have considered the notion ex's brother is very attractive and we have been flirtatious in the past. but i could never do that to my ex or his family, no matter how it ended with him (pretty badly). too bad though, his brother has way more game than he ever will...
msshellokitty msshellokitty 9 years
I could never do that.That would be way too awkward for me.
Phunkometry Phunkometry 9 years
Again, by "dating", I mean seeing each other in the hallways at school, and going to the movies, and that's about it. Yeah.
Phunkometry Phunkometry 9 years
I have. (Oddly enough, I happen to not be a trashy skank.) But this was in 8th grade (my first "boyfriend" lol) and then in 10th grade. But you know. Kid stuff. I was never involved with their family, nothing was serious (at least not in an adult manner; we thought we were "in love", though; I'm not sure where we got that idea), and the brothers had a really distant, strained relationship anyway, so, I dunno. It was like dating two people who happened to live in the same house. It wasn't a big deal.
Dawnie86 Dawnie86 9 years
I would never do that. Its to weird. And its just not right.
swwonder swwonder 9 years
I've been attracted to brothers - they looked really alike (except one had dark hair, the other blond) aside from that they had very unique personalities. I had really liked the older one (he was my age), but we were also good friends so that had already put a strain on our friendship. Then when I got over him I fell for his brother - who liked me a lot too. But at that point it just felt a little weird.
Knight-Who-Says-Ni Knight-Who-Says-Ni 9 years
No way. Talk about inappropriate.
potterlove potterlove 9 years
Two words: sloppy second!!! I wouldn't want to be one, and I wouldn't want to make anybody else one!!!
Selena Gomez's Relationship History
What Is Broken Wing Theory?
Things Latina Grandmas Say
What It's Like to Date Your Best Friend
From Our Partners
Latest Love
All the Latest From Ryan Reynolds