Skip Nav
Halloween
The Story of 2 High School Friends, Her Illness, and Their Halloween Wedding
Nostalgia
10 Group Costumes Inspired by the '90s
Relationships
9 Signs You're Finally Ready to Date After Divorce

Did You Have a Special Teen Heartthrob Obsession?

If you haven't noticed, we have major teen heartthrob obsession going on over here at TrèsSugar. So much so, we put together our very own teen heartthrob bracket. We're asking you to choose the finest, dreamiest, hunkiest, teen squeeze of all time and giving away a free iPad to one lucky voter!

Back in the day, I totally thought Leo DiCaprio was the most perfect looking man I'd ever lay my eyes on. I went to see Titanic three times in the theater, which was actually quite lame compared to one of my classmates who went to see it like 15 times! My sister on the other hand — she had posters of Ryan Phillippe all over her room. I asked her the other day why she was so in love, and she said: "no clue." If Ryan Phillippe prevails against Elvis Presley in round three, and Leonardo DiCaprio beats Heath Ledger, our heartthrobs will come face-to-face in the final four! I know who I'm voting for.

danakscully64 danakscully64 7 years
I'm so glad everyone is admitting to their Jonathan love. :) He was the "it" boy for a very long time, the Rob Pattinson of the 90's. Is it a little pathetic that I still have all of my posters, magazine cutouts, and calenders? Oh, and I also have a Pinocchio doll with a pull string that talks with his voice. Prized possessions, never want to get rid of them. My walls were top to bottom Jonathan. That would still be the case, but I don't think my boyfriend would like that in our apartment. He barely tolerates the X-Files stuff :p
cfeccentric cfeccentric 7 years
Hayden Christensen. I fell in love with him when Star Wars Episode II came out. I also fell in love with Ewan McGregor in Episode I, but mostly I adore him in Moulin Rouge. I would marry him a hundred times over in that movie.
sallyass36 sallyass36 7 years
Jonathan Brandis. I was totally devastated when I found out about his suicide. I LOVED him when I was reading Tiger Beat and whatnot.
danakscully64 danakscully64 7 years
redchicken - Not lame at all. :) I still do that with some of his movies LOL
redchick152 redchick152 7 years
lol...this is a fun post!! :) JTT- i used to rewind the Lion King and watch young-Simba's parts over and over again...LAME! Freddie Prinze Jr- i had a huge crush on him and a girl crush on SMG. they are like my teen-dream-fantasy couple!! Andrew Keegan- Camp Nowhere!!! Nick Carter- i wrote several fan letters...LAME! Val Kilmer- completely random, i know, but he was a fox in Top Gun!
glamourette142 glamourette142 7 years
In 7th grade I was totally crazy for actor Skeet Ulrich, he played Billy Loomis in " Scream".
leeluvfashion leeluvfashion 7 years
A bit difficult to admit however for quite awhile my crush was Aaron Carter. During his "famous" years. I remember being green with envy when a grade school friend had gone to his concert and came back with an autographed CD. Oh the envy... :rotfl: J.C from N'SYNC was 2nd runner-up and Greg Raposo from Dreamstreet 3rd. Wow, I actually had not thought of them in awhile. Funny to think back on and remember the posters I had plastered all over my room ripped out from J14, Teen Beat, etc.
robinlh912 robinlh912 7 years
My walls were floor to ceiling Backstreet Boys, especially Nick. Oh man, the money I could have saved up! :P
xgreenfairyx xgreenfairyx 7 years
Oh, dear...those percentages are...sadly unsurprising.
Rouge14 Rouge14 7 years
Me and my best friend had a list of common crushes! At the top of the Pyramid we had Leonardo DiCaprio as well, there was also Johnny Depp, Devon Sawa, Jonathan Taylor Thomas, Nick Carter (yeah not very proud of that one lol), and River Phoenix (until we quickly learnt he had died when we were still in our diapers, :/) We watched Titanic about 30 times at least (on vhs, dvd, in the theater, in French, in English with subtitles...you name it, we watched it! XD) and all of Leo's other movies as well, we sure knew how to be obsessed! :P
danakscully64 danakscully64 7 years
Currently or in the past? I think I'm 1 inch taller than him :p
EmilieLove EmilieLove 7 years
Aaron Carter...before he went weird. JTT goes to my school. Was MAJORLY disappointed when I saw him around campus and realized that I'm taller than him!
danakscully64 danakscully64 7 years
Devon Sawa as well. :)
skigurl skigurl 7 years
JTT, Devon Sawa, Andrew Keagen in my younger years...and then AJ McLean of Backstreet Boys and a little Nick Carter in my later years plus obviously Leo in Titanic and other various dudes as they came and went
opentypeA opentypeA 7 years
Aaron Carter and Josh Hartnett. Much cuter back in the day! ;-)
weffie weffie 7 years
Tom Cruise (ew, ikr! but it was in the cocktail days!), then Joey McIntyre, then Jason Priestley, then Robert Smith, then Billy Corgan... aside from a brief infatuation with Gavin Rossdale in the mid-90s, I've been all about Billy since sixth grade :)
cupcakers cupcakers 7 years
I was obsessed with Justin Timberlake when NSYNC fist came out and got big.. I remember at the state fair I got to the front and counted that Justin made eye contact with my 8 TIMES! LOL. I was crazy lovestoned hahaha. It's funny because post-NSYNC is when he got considered sexier and more of a hearthrob. but i don't care for him anymore, I find him cocky and full of it-but for some reason back in the day bleached hair JT got my panties in a bunch!!
neonbee neonbee 7 years
I was into Marat Safin (tennis player) a lot. I think I was 10 when I started have a crush on him... Until now, I still like him.
danakscully64 danakscully64 7 years
Yesi - HE'S MINE, YOU CAN'T HAVE HIM! I LOVE HIM MORE, I'M A BIGGER FAN. MINE!!!!! :p:p:p Awww, I loved Jonathan Brandis too. I was so sad when I heard the news of his death.
GummiBears GummiBears 7 years
I want to say no but I lusted after Johnathan Brandis (RIP) pretty hard when he was alive. I still carry a torch for Johnny Depp. *lol*
Who Is the Best Once Upon a Time Character of 2016?
Male Birth Control | Video
Ryan Reynolds and Ryan Gosling Hotness Poll
Who Will Nick Viall Pick on The Bachelor? Poll
From Our Partners
Latest Love
All the Latest From Ryan Reynolds