Skip Nav
Wicked-Awesome Disney Villain Halloween Costumes
32 Sexy GIFs From Tumblr That Will Fog Up Your Screen
3 Things I Wish I'd Known Before Going Wedding Dress Shopping For the First Time

Obama Won't Charge CIA Employees For Torture — Good Call?

Obama Won't Charge CIA Employees For Torture — Good Call?

Individual CIA employees who carried out waterboarding (aka simulated drowning) will not be prosecuted for torture. The Obama administration announced the decision yesterday, while also releasing four "torture" memos from top legal officials in the Bush administration.

Many people are upset by President Obama's decision. Since waterboarding is widely considered to be torture, they think the perpetrators should be brought to justice. By releasing the memos, Obama hopes to at least get the facts out there, so the same thing will not happen again. He said: "This is a time for reflection not retribution."

Would you like to see the individuals who actually tortured suspects put in jail, or did Obama make the right call?


TidalWave TidalWave 8 years
I like what Sayid said in an episode (i think it was him), "Torture doesn't work, but the threat of being tortured does."
Calimie Calimie 8 years
The ones that said such torture was legal: those are the ones who should be charged.
I absolutely disagree with this decision. Our soldiers were sentenced for their following orders, why should these guys receive a get out of jail free card? Nothing good comes out of giving these men a free pass. But, hey, why bother to learn from your history and mistakes. Let's just continue the same behavior, that way we have no moral leg to stand on. Oh-well, if we refuse to punish these people, perhaps the UN, or another nation will be willing to stand up.
staple-salad staple-salad 8 years
I think the people who ordered the torture are the ones that should be prosecuted, however, there should be something done about the people who actually carried it out, but not too sever, since humans are somewhat "programed" to follow orders, as Milgram showed with his famous experiment involving "shocking" a person being tested, as ordered by an authority figure, and as was showed in the Stanford Prison Study (where students role played as guards and inmates, though the experiment had to be cut short due to safety concerns). Point being: the CIA officers aren't wholly responsible for their actions, however, the people who ordered the torture are.
UnDave35 UnDave35 8 years
"Just following orders" isn't a good excuse, since they are commissioned to not follow any orders that they feel is against the Uniform Code of Military Justice. Having said that, this is the correct decision.
luckychick1 luckychick1 8 years
No way should they be punished. They were following orders - orders that were given to help protect our country. I for one am very grateful to them.
untitled1 untitled1 8 years
They need to be punished, being ordered to is not an excuse for torture. I put maybe only because I think the people who told them too should also be punished.
Fallingfromtrees Fallingfromtrees 8 years
Being brought up in a military household, 'following orders" is simply what you do. You listen to whatever your superior officer tells you to do and you dont ask questions. My dad wasn't quite that strict, and usually encouraged us to question what we knew, but not what we were told. So, i dont blame those men personally, i blame their superiors.
hypnoticmix hypnoticmix 8 years
We're not going to prosecute any one regarding this matter because as they say it's not good for the nation. If it were up to me I would look at each individuals involvement and judge it on a case by case basis. I can tell you though if it's a matter of a subordinate doing his/her job with the understanding that it's an order and the U.S. signed off on it they will not be held to blame. The only persons that would have to worry if I were in charge are those in the Justice department who said this was o.k. Not even old Georgie would have to worry about my claws because he sought council and council advised unfortunately they put the United States name on the line and gave horrible advise and they are the ones I would hold to blame Gonzales and his posy.
hope2be hope2be 8 years
Milgram's experiment! Thanks for bringing that up michichan. Learned that one in college, one of the most intriguing things I've learned :D I agree with Obama on this one.
genesisrocks genesisrocks 8 years
I agree with moving on
aimeeb aimeeb 8 years
I agree, just move on.
tinamarie0223 tinamarie0223 8 years
I think that after the Nuremberg trials, "just following orders" is no longer a legal excuse for committing crimes.
dm8bri dm8bri 8 years
I could go either way on the prosecution, but I think Obama made the right decision, and said it best with "nothing will be gained by spending our time and energy laying blame for the past."
cirrus1701 cirrus1701 8 years
I find it mildly ironic that our own boys in the Navy Seals, Delta Force, etc. have to go through FAR worse in their training alone. Sleep deprivation, water boarding to the extreme, tear gas without any gas mask, the list goes on and on. And yes, Obambi made a good call here.
Ac2366 Ac2366 8 years
The Milgram experiment is very interesting! I don't think it's right for people who were following orders to be punished.
Green-Apple Green-Apple 8 years
I don't think this is the same as Nazi Germany but the whole, I was just following orders thing does not work for me either. Nazi soldiers were entirely wrong but faced possible prison and death if they didn't follow orders. CIA torturers faced a pay cut and career change if they chose not to do it. I really think something is wrong with anyone willing to strap someone down and force them to experience the effects of drowning. I would love to see the people who made that decision answer for what they did. I doubt it will happen.
Gdeeaz Gdeeaz 8 years
michichan you beat me to it. i was also going to mention the Milgram experiment.
Chrstne Chrstne 8 years
Torture is wrong. We were even torturing teenage kids who were suspected of terrorism. As far as that goes, many people there are probably not terrorists at all, and for the people who really are, we are no different than they are. No different at all. I wish obama would charge them...because we need to show that this can NEVER happen again, and it was NOT okay to any extend of the imagination.
bethsuga1 bethsuga1 8 years
you cannot legally convict someone who was doing something that was not illegal at time. if they were following order and not purposefuly breaking any laws, there is not a lot that can be done. laws can be made that no one should use torture anymore, but i think obama wants to keep that door open sadly.
CaterpillarGirl CaterpillarGirl 8 years
Good, No prosecution for them, and onward to getting rid of the witch hunt altogether.
michichan michichan 8 years
Come on now, don't judge until you've been in their shoes. Doesn't anyone remember the Milgram experiment?
Witchy-Ways Witchy-Ways 8 years
For me, this isn't just about breaking the law but about being viciously evil toward another human being. I don't care whether or not they were told to do so. If you put authority over treating another person like a human being then I don't even see why prosecution is being questioned in the first place. Get on with it ASAP. And just to be clear, those who gave the orders need to justify their actions in court too, of course.
popgoestheworld popgoestheworld 8 years
I'm torn about this. The whole "I was just following orders" stuff just reeks of Nazi Germany. On the other hand, I agree that we need to move forward and spend our energy on the future instead of the past.
Where the Obamas Lived Before the White House
Obama Laughs at Baby Dressed as Pope and Gives Him Top Prize
Barack and Michelle Obama Best Pictures 2017
Old Donald Trump Tweet on NFL, Redskins, and Barack Obama
From Our Partners
Latest Love
All the Latest From Ryan Reynolds