Skip Nav
Relationships
10 Ways to Fall in Love With Your Partner All Over Again
Women
Unicorn Obsessed? These 36 Magical Costumes Are Marvelous
Sex
6 Strange Things That Can Make You Horny

Proposition 8 Judge Is Gay, Could Be Disqualified

Gay Marriage Opponents Say Gay Judge Can't Rule on Case

Last year, US District Chief Judge Vaughn Walker ruled there was no evidence same-sex marriages harm heterosexual marriages, and thus California's Proposition 8 is unconstitutional. Since then, Judge Walker, a Republican appointed by George Bush Sr., has retired and revealed he is gay and has been in a long-term relationship for 10 years. (Disclaimer: I worked for Judge Walker in the Summer of 2007.)

As you might guess, supporters of Prop. 8 have filed a motion to invalidate Judge Walker's decision because "given that Chief Judge Walker was in a committed, long-term, same-sex relationship throughout this case (and for many years before the case commenced), it is clear that his 'impartiality might reasonably [have been] questioned' from the outset."

Using logic behind the idea Judge Walker has something to gain if Prop. 8 ended, shouldn't straight-married judges be disqualified too, since, as Prop. 8 supporters argue, gay marriage would imminently threaten their marriages? Implying a straight judge would have nothing at stake seems to undermine the argument for a gay marriage ban in the first place. Not to mention, if a gay judge can't rule on a gay discrimination case, can a female judge work on a sex discrimination case? What about an African-American judge presiding over a race discrimination case?

Despite his sexuality, Judge Walker has found himself on the other side of the gay rights debate. When he was a lawyer, he represented the US Olympic Committee in a suit preventing a San Francisco group from calling its competition the "Gay Olympics." That position, which was considered anti-gay, caused liberals to block his first nomination by Ronald Reagan. Based on the fact Prop. 8 proponents only called two witnesses and failed to convince Gov. Arnold Schwarzenegger and California's attorney generals to defend the ban, this seems less about Judge Walker's impartiality, and more like a last-ditch attempt to throw out Judge Walker's unfavorable ruling. Do you think they have any chance?

insidiousmiss insidiousmiss 6 years
Excellent argument, Annie. Unfortunately, I suspect that opponents of gay rights aren't much interested in logic.
stephley stephley 6 years
Prop 8 proponents are just desperate. A straight divorced or married judge would have equal cause for bias.
Youth Suicide Rates Lower After Gay Marriage Was Legalized
Courthouse Wedding
Restaurant Courtyard Wedding
United Airlines Detained Father For Touching Son
From Our Partners
Latest Love
All the Latest From Ryan Reynolds